Top financial innovations in the 20th century

Top financial innovations in the 20th century

Nithisha CHALLA

In this article, Nithisha CHALLA (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole Program – Master in Management (MiM), 2021-2024) presents top financial innovations of the 20th century that have brought significant changes in people’s life.

Introduction

Financial innovations have significantly transformed how people make transactions and manage money like saving and investing. These innovations have increased accessibility, convenience, and security in financial activities, benefiting individuals and companies alike. From the introduction of paper money in ancient China to modern-day digital banking, each era has brought new ways to manage finances. The 20th century has seen rapid advancements due to technology, leading to groundbreaking changes in financial services.

Top Financial Innovations that Changed People’s Life in the 20th century

Our selection of financial innovations is based on their wide adoption by firms and individuals (usage in many countries worldwide).

  • Credit Cards and Debit Cards: Introduced in the 1950s, credit and debit cards provided a convenient way for consumers to make purchases without cash, leading to a shift towards a cashless society.
  • Automated Teller Machines (ATMs): ATMs revolutionized banking by allowing customers to perform transactions anytime, anywhere, without needing to visit a bank branch.
  • Telephone Banking: The rise of the internet in the 1980s enabled banks to allow customers to perform basic banking transactions, such as checking account balances and transferring funds, via phone.
  • Online Banking: The rise of the internet in the 1990s enabled banks to offer online services, making it easier for customers to manage accounts, pay bills, and transfer money.

We explain below how these financial innovations impacted people’s lives and companies. We also give some statistics to measure the impact.

Credit Cards and Debit Cards

The Diners Club card, introduced by Frank McNamara card in 1950, is considered the first credit. Later, Bank of America launched the BankAmericard (now Visa) in 1958. Later, Visa became one of the largest credit card issuers globally. MasterCard, originally Interbank Card Association, formed in 1966, is another major player in the credit card industry. The concept of a debit card was first introduced by the First National Bank of Seattle in 1966. The first debit card was issued by Barclays in the UK in 1966.

These Credit and Debit cards provided consumers a convenient and secure way to purchase without carrying cash. It allowed for the development of the credit industry, enabling consumers to borrow funds for purchases and pay them back over time. Which also helped customers make larger purchases thus improving purchasing power.

To speak on how much these innovations affected people, by the end of the 20th century, there were over 1 billion credit cards in use globally. And in 2019, Visa and MasterCard together processed over 171 billion transactions worldwide. In terms of debit card transactions, it recorded over 100 billion debit card transactions globally in 2020.

First ever credit card picture
First ever credit card picture
Source: Time news letter

Figure 1 below presents the evolution of the size of the credit card industry in the United States from 2013 to 2023.

Figure 1. The market size of the US credit card industry
US market evolution of Credit cards industry
Source: Time news letter

Automated Teller Machines (ATMs)

John Shepherd-Barron is credited with inventing the first ATM, which was installed by Barclays Bank in London in 1967. Later, Diebold Nixdorf and NCR Corporation became the major manufacturers of ATMs in the 1980s.

These ATMs provided 24/7 access to banking services, allowing customers to withdraw cash, check balances, and perform other transactions without needing to visit a bank branch. Hence, it enhanced convenience and reduced the need for in-person banking services. Helping reduce queues at banks and improve transaction speed. Overall, this innovation has increased accessibility, convenience, and efficiency both for banks and consumers.

To speak on how much these innovations affected people, by 1990, there were around 100,000 ATMs worldwide. As of 2020, there are approximately 3.2 million ATMs globally. The global ATM market was valued at around $18.4 billion in 2019.

First ever ATM picture
 First ever ATM picture
Source: Time news letter

Figure 2 below presents the evolution of the globally installed ATM bases in the period of 2009 to 2020.

Figure 2. ATM global evolution

Source: Time news letter

Telephone Banking

Midland Bank (now part of HSBC) launched the first telephone banking service in the UK in 1989. HSBC pioneered telephone banking services and Citibank also offered telephone banking as part of its service portfolio being one of the early adopters of telephone banking. This is considered the innovation of the 1980-1990 decade.

This innovation has allowed customers to perform basic banking transactions, such as checking account balances and transferring funds, via phone. Provided a convenient alternative to visiting a bank branch, especially for those without internet access, and reduced risks associated with carrying cash or checks.

To speak on how much these innovations affected people, by the late 1990s, telephone banking was widely adopted, with millions of users globally. Despite the rise of online and mobile banking in the 21st century, telephone banking remains a valuable service for many customers, particularly the elderly and those in rural areas. In 2019, an estimated 5% of U.S. adults still used telephone banking. And by 2000, more than 50% of U.S. banks offered telephone banking services.

Figure 1 shows what the first-ever telephone banking machine looked like in 1973.

First ever touch-tone telephone banking machine in 1973.
 First ever telephone banking machine picture
Source: ZB Media

Online Banking

The concept of online baking was developed by banks like Stanford Federal Credit Union, which offered the first online banking services in 1994. Bank of America was one of the early adopters of online banking and Wells Fargo Launched its first Internet banking service in 1995.

This innovation has provided customers with the ability to manage their accounts, pay bills, transfer funds, and perform other banking activities from the comfort of their homes. It reduced the need for physical bank branches and made banking services more accessible.

To speak on how much these innovations affected people, by 2019, 76% of U.S. adults used online banking. The global online banking market was valued at $9.2 billion US dollars in 2019. And global online banking users are expected to reach 2.5 billion by 2024.

First ever Online banking machine in 1980.
 First ever Online banking machine picture
Source: Fintech Magazine

Figure 1 shows what the first-ever Online banking machine looked like in 1980.

Conclusion

Financial innovations have profoundly transformed the way individuals and businesses interact with money. From the widespread adoption of credit cards to mobile payments these innovations have made financial services more accessible, efficient, and secure. As technology continues to advance, the financial landscape will undoubtedly see further changes, continuing to shape and improve people’s lives worldwide.

Why should I be interested in this post?

Management students, as future leaders and decision-makers, should understand financial innovations for several compelling reasons. These innovations not only influence the financial landscape but also have significant implications for strategic decision-making, operational efficiency, and competitive advantage.

Related posts on the SimTrade blog

   ▶ Nithisha CHALLA Top financial innovations in the 21st century

Useful resources

Wikipedia Financial Innovation

Fintech Magazine Online Banking 1973 – History of Computers

ZB Media Technology in Fintech and the story of Online Banking

Research gate The emergence of financial innovation and its governance – a historical literature review

Axis bank Credit card: A cashless surge

Cambridge University Press Banking and Finance in the Twentieth Century

About the author

The article was written in August 2024 by Nithisha CHALLA (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole Program – Master in Management (MiM), 2021-2024).

Mitigation Banking

Mitigation Banking

Anant Jain

In this article, Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2019-2022) talks about Mitigation Banking which is a mechanism to preserve the ecosystem.

Introduction

Mitigation banking is a system of credits and debits devised by regulatory agencies to ensure that development impacts on wetlands and streams by private companies, as well as rare species and habitats, are offset by the preservation, enhancement, restoration, or creation (PERC) of similar ecological features in nearby areas, ensuring that local ecosystems are not harmed. This system is mainly used in the United States. To ‘mitigate’ anything implies to lessen the severity of it, to compensate for a loss, in this case the environmental harm.

As per the statement by the Ecological Restoration Business Association (ERBA), “mitigation banks are highly regulated enterprises that have historically been proven to deliver the highest quality, most reliable offset to environmental impacts…and a private investment into ‘green infrastructure’ to help offset the impacts associated with economic growth.”

A mitigation bank is a place created specifically for this purpose. A mitigation banker is a person or company that does this type of business. Mitigation credits are assets that may be sold to persons who are striving to comply with particular environmental standards and balance ecological damage they are responsible for. These credits are known as “ecological assets” when they are sold on an active market. They may be likened to other extractable natural resources such as minerals, oil, and natural gas in this regard.

Individuals or businesses conducting commercial or industrial projects that must adhere to state and federal environmental standards are often the buyers of mitigation credits.

There are two types of mitigation banks which are mentioned below:

Wetland And Stream Banks

Wetland and stream banks provide credits to counteract wetlands and streams’ ecological damage. The USACE (Army Corps of Engineers) and the USEPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency) regulate and authorize these banks (Environmental Protection Agency). Wetland banks are still referred to as “mitigation banks” since they were the first sort of offset scheme to be established. However, wetland and stream banks, as well as conservation banks, are now referred to as Mitigation Banks.

Conversation Banks

Conservation banks provide credits to compensate for the loss of rare or unique species and/or their habitats, which are often categorized as threatened or endangered under state and federal regulations. USFWS (Fish and Wildlife Service) and NMFS (National Marine Fisheries Service) regulate and authorize these banks (National Marine Fisheries Service). Unlike wetland and stream banks that focus on a given area, conservation banks deals with species.

The Process Of Mitigation Banking

When a mitigation bank buys a degraded site that it wants to restore, it engages with regulatory bodies like the Mitigation Banking Review Team (MBRT) and the Conservation Banking Review Team (CBRT) to have plans approved for the bank’s construction, maintenance, and monitoring.

These organizations also provide their approval to the quantity of mitigation credits a bank can earn and sell in connection with a certain restoration project. These mitigation credits can be purchased by anybody planning commercial development on or near a wetland or stream in order to mitigate the detrimental impact of their project on the surrounding ecology. The mitigation banker is in charge of not only the mitigation bank’s development, but also its ongoing care and maintenance.

Figure 1. Mitigation Banking Process.
Mitigation Banking Process/Flow
Source: EASI

As depicted above in Figure 1, the US Environmental Protection Agency has established four main components of a mitigation bank:

  • The actual area that is repaired, developed, upgraded, or conserved is referred to as the bank site.
  • The bank instrument is a written agreement between bank owners and regulators that establishes liabilities, performance criteria, management and monitoring requirements, and loan approval terms.
  • The Interagency Assessment Team (IRT) is a multi-agency group that oversees the bank’s regulatory review, approval, and monitoring.
  • The service area is the geographical region for which a development project can pay the bank for permissible damages.

Benefits Of Mitigation Banking

The following mentioned below are the benefits of mitigation banking:

Conservation And Protection Of The Environment

Mitigation banks create a permanent conservation easement on the site, with a trust fund committed to the long-term preservation of the bank’s natural resources. Many large landowners, including the government, are able to maintain a property in its current management state (for example, grazing, timber removal, low-impact recreation, or education) while retaining ecological functionality, also known as ecosystem services, by securing mitigation credits from neighboring ecosystems. As a result, mitigation banking contributes to the preservation of nature and its variety. Increased industrialization and urbanization will inevitably have an influence on natural ecosystems, streams, and wetlands. Mitigation banks offer a way to at least somewhat mitigate this effect.

Increased Efficiency

To counteract each specific development, a mitigation bank is more efficient than restoring a distinct biological location. This is because restoring a large, contiguous piece of land is easier than preserving a number of smaller locations. A mitigation bank’s economies of scale and technical competence make it more efficient not just in terms of cost, but also in terms of recovered acreage (an area of land usually used for agricultural purposes) quality.

Regulatory Ease And Reduced Time Lag

Buying credits from an approved mitigation bank is easier for developers than obtaining regulatory permissions, which may take months. Mitigation banks, on the other hand, have already restored impacted acreage units in the process of obtaining credits. As a result, there is little to no time between a service area’s environmental effect and its rehabilitation at a bank site.

Transfer Of Liability

The mitigation banking mechanism effectively transfers ecological loss obligation from the developer (also known as permittee) to the mitigation banker. Once the permittee has purchased the requisite credits, the mitigation banker is responsible for developing, maintaining, and monitoring the site on a long-term basis. If no qualifying mitigation bank exists in a given location, the developer might design their own mitigation project to compensate for environmental loss. Permittee-responsible mitigation is what it’s termed.

Challenges Of Mitigation Banking

The following mentioned below are the challenges of mitigation banking:

Incorrect Valuation Of Ecological Loss

The difficulty of accurately measuring ecological loss in monetary terms is the most significant barrier for successful mitigation banking. Regulators must price and analyze the credits granted to mitigation banks, but despite the adoption of a variety of environmental assessment tools by these agencies, it is difficult to adequately capture the economic cost of natural resource destruction.

Difference In The Quality Of Artificial VS Natural Wetlands

It is debatable if natural ecosystems like wetlands, which have evolved over generations, can be intentionally built in a matter of years. In certain situations, the quality of these intentionally created wetlands has been shown to be inferior to its wild counterparts in terms of floral and faunal richness.

Only Partial Replication Of Impacted Sites

Mitigation banks, as opposed to individual mitigation in which developers establish their own mitigation sites in the neighborhood of acres damaged, are thought to be positioned distant from the impact locations and hence unable to entirely recreate the impacted site.

Summarizing The Current Situation Of Mitigation Banks In The US

  • Mitigation banking is a methodology that provides a system of credits and debits to transfer accountability for ecological harm from the permittee to the mitigation banker, all while adhering to regulatory rules. A mitigation banker builds, restores, maintains, and administers the land at a bank site in order to gain mitigation credits, which are then sold for a charge to a permittee or developer.
  • Mitigation banking is a lengthy and complicated procedure. The most crucial aspect is site selection: the mitigation banker must conduct extensive study about the site’s watershed and service region, as well as identify ecosystems that require restoration and augmentation. The mitigation banker is in charge of maintaining and monitoring the restored environment once all of the permissions are in place.
  • A wetland mitigation bank must be capable of restoring 100 acres of damaged wetlands, while a stream mitigation bank must be capable of restoring 4,000 linear feet of degraded streams. Sites that don’t fit these criteria can be grouped together with others in the same watershed to form an umbrella mitigation bank.
  • Because only related ecosystems may mitigate development projects, the cost of mitigation bank credits will vary greatly depending on location and effect activities. An emerging wetland credit in Iowa, US, for example, might cost anywhere from $35,000 to $55,000 per acre, while a forested wetland credit can cost up to $75,000.
  • In the United States, a number of mitigation banks have been approved. According to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ (USACE) Regulatory In-Lieu Fee and Bank Information Tracking System (RIBITS), there were over 2,000 licensed banks as of July 2021.
  • Despite regulations requiring no net loss of habitat value and function, agencies have struggled to manage mitigation efforts. Wetland mitigation initiatives, for example, have been approved in certain circumstances based on total acreage rather than ecological value or function equivalent. Simply assuming a similar number of acres isn’t enough to achieve real equivalence unless the replacement ecological services provided by those acres are also the same. Even with the application of environmental assessment tools, regulatory agencies confront a problem in determining the right economic or monetary value for ecological damage. Despite the fact that mitigation banks must be placed in the same watershed as the damage to be deemed acceptable compensation, mitigation banks are frequently located far from the actual impact location. As a result, retaining the original value and function is challenging.
  • Despite some of its flaws, it nevertheless offers a number of benefits. The future of mitigation banking is bright for both project developers and nature, with increased private investment in the establishment of mitigation banks and ecosystem research, as well as reducing regulatory regulations.

Related Posts On The SimTrade Blog

Useful Resources

Ecological Restoration Business Association (ERBA)

USACE (Army Corps of Engineers)

USEPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency)

USFWS (Fish and Wildlife Service)

NMFS (National Marine Fisheries Service)

About The Author

The article was written in August 2024 by Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Master in Management, 2019-2022).

Mission Statement

Mission Statement

Anant Jain

In this article, Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2019-2022) talks about Mission Statement.

Introduction

A mission statement explains an organization’s purpose of existence. A mission statement defines the organization’s values, ethics, culture, goals, and agenda. It describes the rationale for its existence, specifies its overall goals, and identifies the operational goals (including the product and/or service to deliver, its key clients or market, and the geographical region of operations) in basic and brief terms. A mission statement would be unique and distinct for every organization because every organization is different in terms of history, business, operations, vision, etc.

For example, the mission statement for United Airlines is as follows: “Connecting people. Uniting the world.”

In addition to this, a mission statement also entails how each and every component is applicable to the distinct and various stakeholders of an organization including its employees, customers, suppliers, investors, and society at large. Therefore, it can be used by various stakeholders to assess if an organization’s values and goals align with their own or not.

For example, Nike’s mission statement includes various stakeholder presented ahead: “To expand human potential by creating groundbreaking sport innovations, by making our products more sustainably, by building a creative and diverse global team and by making a positive impact in communities where we live and work.”

A mission statement is an action-oriented declaration of an organization’s purpose to its target audience. A broad explanation of the organization, its role, and its goals is frequently included. As an organization expands, its aims and goals may be met, and they may alter as a result. When a result, as prior goals are fulfilled, mission statements should be amended as appropriate to reflect the organization’s new culture.

A commercial mission statement, according to Chris Bart, professor of strategy and governance at McMaster University, consists of three fundamental components:

  • Key market: the target market for the organization
  • Contribution: the product or service that has been provided
  • Distinction: what distinguishes the product or why should the audience choose it over another

However, Bart (2006) estimates that only around 10 percent of mission statements are useful in practice. As a result, they are commonly viewed with contempt.

Examples Of Mission Statements

Please find below a list of mission statement for some of the most famous companies which I personally found to be concrete & impactful:

  • IKEA: To create a better everyday life for the many people.
  • Nordstrom: To give customers the most compelling shopping experience possible.
  • JetBlue: To inspire humanity – both in the air and on the ground.
  • Workday: To put people at the center of enterprise software.
  • Tesla: To accelerate the world’s transition to sustainable energy.
  • TED: Spread ideas.
  • Chipotle: To provide “food with integrity.”
  • Walmart: We save people money so they can live better.
  • Starbucks: To inspire and nurture the human spirit—one person, one cup, and one neighborhood at a time.
  • JP Morgan: To be the best financial services company in the world.
  • ESSEC Business School: The mission of ESSEC Business School, a world school with French roots, is to infuse leadership with meaning in order to prepare leaders ready to address contemporary economic, environmental and social challenges. In order to do so, it produces innovative and relevant knowledge to equip the next generation of leaders with the skills, know-how and savoir-être that will make them truly responsible, inclusive and respectful of the environment. Convinced that knowledge provides a path to freedom – Per scientiam ad libertatem – ESSEC inculcates in its students critical thinking and creativity skills that prepare them to anticipate and address the challenges of an increasingly uncertain world. ESSEC supports students in making their actions both meaningful and impactful by relying on both technology and people. It also seeks to enlighten the actions of businesses and organizations in a world transformed by the new industrial revolution, the environmental crisis, a new world balance and other major societal changes.

Purpose Of A Mission Statement

Although the concept of an organization’s purpose may extend beyond that of a mission statement, the primary objective of a commercial mission statement is to define an organization’s core aim/agenda, and it outlines the same in simple words. Businesses use mission statements to communicate not just to themselves and their employees, but also to consumers and other stakeholders. An organization’s mission statement will change as it grows. This is to guarantee that the business stays on course and that the mission statement does not lose its luster and become uninteresting or stale.

Because all strategies are formed and executed with a strong objective as the foundation, being able to construct an impactful statement is the first step to commercial success. The mission statement directs the management team in developing strategies that enable the organization to reinforce its identity and achieve its objectives. It is necessary for:

  • Employee motivation
  • Customer inspiration
  • Strategic planning
  • Establishment of values
  • Understanding why an organization operates

Advantages Of A Mission Statement

The following are some of the benefits of a mission statement:

Provides guidance and direction

Mission statement contributes to the organization’s ability to make better decisions, which can benefit them. Organizations may struggle to make decisions and prepare for the future if they don’t have a mission statement to guide them. This is why one of the most useful aspects of a goal statement is offering guidance.

Clear And Well-Defined Goal/Purpose

Having a defined mission might help to eliminate any potential uncertainties about an organization’s existence. People who are interested in the organization’s success, such as stakeholders, will want to know that the organization is making the correct decisions and moving closer to its objectives, which will assist to dispel any doubts the stakeholders may have.

A mission statement may be used as a motivator inside an organization, allowing employees to work together toward a common objective that benefits both the organization and the employees. Employee’s happiness and productivity may both benefit from this. It’s critical for employees to have a feeling of purpose. Giving them a feeling of purpose will allow them to concentrate more on their everyday activities while also assisting them in realizing the organizations and their own goals.

Disadvantages And Flaws Of Mission Statements

Even though a mission statement is generally useful to an organization, it does have a few drawbacks, which are listed below:

Unrealistic

Mission statements are frequently found to be unrealistic and too optimistic. A mission statement that is unrealistic can have a negative impact on staff performance and morale. Because an unachievable purpose statement reduces the possibility that employees will be able to reach this objective, it may demotivate employees in the long run. Unrealistic mission statements likewise serve no value and are a waste of effort for management. Another issue that might result from an unachievable mission statement is that in order to attain this objective, incorrect judgments may be made, which could hurt the organization.

Waste Of Resources And Time

Mission statements need planning. For individuals in charge of writing the mission statement, this requires time and effort. It may be result in ineffective use of tuime and resources. If the mission statement is not accomplished, the process of developing it might be viewed as a waste of time by all parties concerned. A strong mission statement may take a lot of effort and work to create, and organizations cannot afford to waste any of that time. The time may have been better spent on other vital responsibilities inside the organization, such as decision-making.

Mission Statement VS Vision Statement

An organization’s mission statement explains what it aims to accomplish, who it wants to help, and why it wants to support them. A vision statement, on the other hand, defines where the organization wants a community or the world to be as a result of its services. As a result, a mission statement serves as a road map for the organization’s goal.

A mission statement states what a brand or organization intends to accomplish. This informs the public about the product and service it offers, as well as who it serves and why it does so. A brand’s vision statement is a declaration that looks to the future and expresses what it aims to accomplish through its mission statement. This is more conceptual, since it shows what the brand may become in the eyes of the consumer, as well as the value it will provide in the long run.

To sum it up, the following are the fundamental distinctions between a mission and a vision statement:

  • Mission statements define an organization’s present mission. A mission statement frequently includes information about the organization’s role, target audience, and significant offers.
  • Vision statements are a glimpse into an organization’s future or a declaration of the organization’s overarching vision. A vision statement can have the same aspects as a mission statement; however, it will be expressed in the future tense.

Related Posts On The SimTrade Blog

▶ Anant JAIN Analysis Of “The Social Responsibility Of Business Is To Create Value For Stakeholders” Article By Freeman And Elms

▶ Anant JAIN Stakeholder

▶ Anant JAIN Shareholder

▶ Anant JAIN Writing A Mission Statement

Useful resources

Christpher K. Bart (2006) Sex, Lies and Mission Statements

About The Author

The article was written in August 2024 by Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2019-2022).

Writing A Mission Statement

Writing A Mission Statement

Anant Jain

In this article, Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2019-2022) talks about how to write a mission statement.

Introduction

A mission statement explains an organization’s purpose of existence. A mission statement defines the organization’s values, ethics, culture, goals, and agenda. It describes the rationale for its existence, specifies its overall goals, and identifies the operational goals (including the product and/or service to deliver, its key clients or market, and the geographical region of operations) in basic and brief terms. A mission statement would be unique and distinct for every organization because every organization is different in terms of history, business, operations, vision, etc.

In addition to this, a mission statement also entails how each and every component is applicable to the distinct and various stakeholders of an organization including its employees, customers, suppliers, investors, and society at large. Therefore, it can be used by various stakeholders to assess if an organization’s values and goals align with their own or not.

For example, United Airlines: “Connecting people. Uniting the world.”

A commercial mission statement, according to Chris Bart, professor of strategy and governance at McMaster University, consists of three fundamental components:

  • Key market: the target market for the organization
  • Contribution: the product or service that has been provided
  • Distinction: what distinguishes the product or why should the audience choose it over another

Drafting A Mission Statement

While it may be tough to condense your organization’s emphasis into a single sentence, here are some pointers to help you draft an effective mission statement.

1. First, start by describing what the organization does. This may be a product you create or a service it offers to your customers—whatever it is that keeps the organization running.

2. Secondly, outline how the organization accomplishes its goals. Instead of becoming technical, consider what values are at the heart of the organization. Perhaps it places a premium on quality, customer service, or sustainability, or it encourage creativity and innovation. In its mission statement, it should include these crucial aspects.

3. Finally, in a mission statement, explain “why it does what it does”. This is crucial. It allows it to stand out as an organization by emphasizing what makes it unique in its field. Keep the mission statement succinct and to-the-point.

Remember to go over it, modify it, and have someone else look it over when you’ve finished it. It will need to find a method to include it anywhere you can after you’ve authorized it, such as on your website or in your marketing campaigns—anywhere that key stakeholders will see it.

As a result, an organization should undertake the following in order to produce a succinct and crisp mission statement:

  • Describe the product or service that an organization provides.
  • Find out what the organization’s essential values are.
  • Make a connection between how your organization’s offering and your ideals.
  • Combine these statements into a single statement.
  • Make sure it is succinct, straightforward, and devoid of fluff.

4. Be inspiring. After drafting the mission statement, one should review each and every word again and question if every word has a meaning associated to the statement or not. Additionally, one should read the mission statement to check if it inspires to spring into action.

5. Use It. You should not spend time on the mission statement if it will not be utilized from your end and will end up becoming just a poster for the hanger wall. On the contrary, your mission statement must become a strong point of reference to analyze any possible future projects and analyze if they align with actualizing the vision.

Related Posts On The SimTrade Blog

▶ Anant JAIN Analysis Of “The Social Responsibility Of Business Is To Create Value For Stakeholders” Article By Freeman And Elms

▶ Anant JAIN Stakeholder

▶ Anant JAIN Shareholder

▶ Anant JAIN Mission Statement

Useful Resources

Christpher K. Bart (2006) Sex, Lies and Mission Statements

About The Author

The article was written in August 2024 by Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2019-2022).

Stakeholder

Stakeholder

Anant Jain

In this article, Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Master in Management, 2019-2022) explains the term “Stakeholder” used in management.

Introduction

As defined in a 1963 internal memorandum at the Stanford Research Institute, “In a company, a stakeholder is a member of groups without whose support the organization would cease to exist”. Edward Freeman later refined and promoted the idea of stakeholder in the 1980s.

In other words, a stakeholder is a person, a group, or an organization who is affected by a company, project, or business venture’s outcome. A stakeholder has an interest in a firm and can influence or be influenced by it.

Stakeholders are crucial because their decisions can have a favorable or negative impact on the project. Diverse stakeholders have different interests, and firms frequently have to make trade-offs in order to please every type of stakeholder.

Investors, employees, customers, and suppliers are the major stakeholders of a typical company. However, with the rise of corporate social responsibility, the notion of stakeholder has been expanded to encompass communities, governments, and trade groups.

Types Of Stakeholders

Stakeholders can be classified on the basis of their engagement and involvement with a company and its business. They can be classified as internal stakeholders and external stakeholders.

Internal Stakeholders

Internal stakeholders, also known as Primary stakeholders, are those who are engaged in economic and financial transactions with the company. Internal stakeholders are those who have a direct interest in the company via employment, ownership, or investment. Employees, owners, the board of directors, project managers, investors, and suppliers are just a few examples.

External Stakeholders

External stakeholders are those who are not engaged in direct economic or financial return with the company and are indirectly impacted by the company and its business activities. They do not actively work for a firm, but they are influenced by its activities and its’ consequences in some way. The government, the environment, society, communities, the general public, and the media are just a few examples.

List Of Stakeholders

As previously stated, there are several categories of stakeholders. There are internal and external stakeholders, and every stakeholder falls under either of these categories. Every type of stakeholder group is unique and their expectations are different. Therefore, some stakeholders will be simpler to handle than others. Please find a list of the most frequent stakeholders, as well as their specific needs and participation with a company, below:

  • Customers

    Stake: Product/service quality and value
    Type of stakeholder: Internal
    These stakeholders desire the project’s product or service, and they want it to be of high quality and provide value for them. For instance, a customer staying at a hotel would expect his or her stay to be convenient and relaxing.

  • Employees

    Stake: Employment income and safety
    Type of stakeholder: Internal
    Employees have a direct investment in the company since they earn a living wage and receive additional perks (both financial and non-monetary). Employees may also have health and safety interest, depending on the nature of the company. This is particularly true for companies in the transportation, mining, oil & gas, and construction sector.

  • Investors

    Stake: Financial returns
    Type of stakeholder: Internal
    Shareholders and debtholders are both types of investors. Investors contribute money into the company with the expectation of getting a particular return on their investment. The idea of shareholder value is often a source of priority for investors. All shareholders are stakeholders by definition, however, the reverse is not true.

  • Suppliers & Vendors

    Stake: Revenues and safety
    Type of stakeholder: External
    Suppliers and vendors offer goods and/or services to a company and rely on it for ongoing revenue and profits. Suppliers’ health and safety are at risk in many sectors, as they may be directly involved in the company’s activities.

  • Communities

    Stake: Health, safety, economic development
    Type of stakeholder: External
    Communities have an important role in the success of significant companies that are based there. Employment opportunity, economic development, health, and safety are all factors that have an influence on them. When a large company moves into or out of a small town, it has an immediate and considerable influence on employment, income, and expenditure.

  • Governments

    Stake: Taxes and GDP
    Type of stakeholder: External
    Governments may also be considered a big shareholder in a company since they collect taxes from the company (corporate income taxes), all the people it employs (payroll taxes), and other expenses the company incurs (sales taxes). Furthermore, companies contribute to the total Gross Domestic Product (GDP), which benefits the governments and as a result, the economy as well.

  • Problems With Stakeholders

    Stakeholders are critical for several reasons. Internal stakeholders are crucial since the company’s operations rely on their ability to collaborate to achieve the company’s objectives. External stakeholders, on the other hand, might have an indirect impact on the company. Customers, for example, can alter their purchasing patterns, suppliers can alter their production and distribution processes, and governments can alter their laws and regulations.

    The various stakeholder interests may not align, which is a significant difficulty for companies with many stakeholders. In actuality, the interests of different stakeholders might be completely poles apart from each other. For example, from the perspective of its shareholders, a company’s principal purpose is to maximize earnings and increase shareholder value. Because labor expenses are inescapable for most businesses, a company may try to reduce them as low as possible as therefore, affecting its credibility with its employees. Ultimately, maintaining internal and external stakeholder relationships and their expectations is critical for a company’s long-term success.

    Stakeholders VS Shareholders

    Shareholders and stakeholders are not the same thing. A stakeholder might be affected by or invested in the project. A stakeholder can be a shareholder. However, stakeholders can also be employees, bondholders, consumers, suppliers, and vendors.

    A shareholder can be a stakeholder. A stakeholder is someone who has interest in a company and may affect or be affected by the company’s actions. A shareholder, on the other hand, is someone who has made a financial investment in a company. Because shareholders are also stakeholders, that company may begin initiatives in which the shareholder is also a stakeholder. However, stakeholders are not always shareholders. Because a shareholder buys stock in a public company, he or she owns a part of the company and therefore is concerned with the performance of the stock. On the other hand, a stakeholder has an interest in the company’s overall performance and not just the stock performance and financial returns.

    Shareholders are an essential form of stakeholder, but they are far from the only ones. Employees, consumers, suppliers, governments, and the general public are examples of other stakeholders. In recent years, there has been a movement toward thinking about who makes up a company’s stakeholders in a broader sense.

    Related Posts On The SimTrade Blog

    ▶ Anant JAIN Analysis Of “The Social Responsibility Of Business Is To Create Value For Stakeholders” Article By Freeman And Elms

    ▶ Anant JAIN Shareholder

    ▶ Anant JAIN Mission Statement

    ▶ Anant JAIN Writing A Mission Statement

    Useful Resources

    Freeman E., H. Elms, 2018, The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Create Value for Stakeholders, MIT Sloan Management Review, 17/12/2020.

    Jack Welch (2009) Welch condemns share price focus Financial Times.

    About the author

    The article was written in August 2024 by Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Master in Management, 2019-2022).

Shareholder

Shareholder

Anant Jain

In this article, Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2019-2022) defines the term “Shareholders”.

Introduction

A shareholder, also known as a stockholder, is a person, company, institution, or any other legal entity that holds stock in a company and is registered as the legal owner of shares of a public or private company’s share capital. To be a partial owner of a company’s stock or mutual fund, a shareholder must hold at least one share. A person or legal entity becomes a shareholder in a company once its name and other details are registered in the company’s register of shareholders or members.

The ownership percentage held determines a shareholder’s influence on the company. A company’s shareholders are legally distinct from the company itself. They are normally not accountable for the company’s obligations, and their liability for business debts is restricted to the paid share price unless a shareholder has been offered guarantees. Since shareholders are technically the owner of the company, they benefit from the success, growth and profitability of a company. These benefits take the shape of higher stock prices and/or dividends. When a company loses money, the share price lowers, which can result in shareholders losing money or seeing their portfolios suffer losses.

Shareholders may have purchased their shares in the primary market by subscribing to initial public offerings (IPOs), and thereby given money to the company. Most shareholders, on the other hand, buy shares in the secondary market and do not contribute to the capital of the company directly. Depending on the share class, shareholders may be offered unique privileges.

Shareholders purchase stock in a firm with the goal of profiting from dividend payments or an increase in the market price of the stock. They may also purchase stock in order to take control of a company.

Shareholders have specific rights, including the ability to vote on certain company affairs, vote for the Board of Directors or be elected to a seat on the Board of Directors, receive dividends from the company, and receive its annual financial statements. A company’s board of directors supervises a company in general for the interest of its stockholders (fiduciary duty).

If the company is dissolved and its assets are sold, the shareholder may be entitled to a percentage of the proceeds (in proportion to the shares held by him or her), assuming all creditors have been paid. When this situation arises, a shareholder does have the obligation to bear the company’s debts and financial commitments, which means creditors cannot force stockholders to pay them.

A majority shareholder is a single shareholder who owns and controls more than 50% of a company’s outstanding shares. Minority shareholders, on the other hand, are individuals who own less than 50% of a corporation’s equity.

Typically, majority shareholders are the founders of companies, while majority shareholders in older companies are frequently descendants of company’s founders. In any scenario, majority shareholders hold more than 50% of the voting rights and as a result, wield enormous authority over important operational decisions, including the replacement of board members and the appopointments of C-level executives such as the chief executive officers (CEO) and other senior employees. Consequently, companies frequently strive to not have any majority shareholder amongst their ranks.

Types Of Shareholders

There are different types of share holders. They can be categorized on the basis of the kind of shares owned, the % of shared owned and ownership’s representation.

On The Basis Of The Kind Of Shares Owned

Common Shareholder

Those who own a company’s common shares (or regular shares) are called common shareholders. This is the most typical shareholding structure. They are the most common form of stockholder, and they have the ability to vote on company’s affairs. They have the right to participate in general meetings of the corporation, in the election of directors, and they can initiate class action lawsuits, when necessary, because they have authority over the governance of the company.

Preferred Shareholder

Preferred shareholders possess a share of the company’s preferred shares/stocks rather than regular shares. They have no voting rights or influence over how the company is operated. They are instead entitled to a predetermined yearly dividend, which will precede the payout before dividends are distributed among the common shareholders.

Therefore, while both common stock and preferred stock appreciate in value as the firm performs well, it is the former that enjoys greater capital gains or losses.

On The Basis Of The Percentage Of Shares Owned

Majority Shareholder

A majority shareholder is someone who actually owns more than 50 percent of a company’s stock. Company’s founders or their successors are typically this type of shareholder.

Minority Shareholder

Minority shareholders own less than 50% of a company’s shares, often as little as one share.

On The Basis Of Ownership’s Representation

Beneficial Shareholder

A person or legal entity that receives financial and economic benefit of ownership of the shares are called Beneficial Shareholders.

Nominee Shareholder

A nominee shareholder is a person or legal entity mentioned as the owner on the company’s register of members, but who, whether disclosed or not, operates for the benefit or at the direction of the beneficial shareholders.

The Rights Of Shareholders

Shareholders may have the following rights, subject to relevant legislation, corporate rules, and any shareholders’ agreement:

  • The right to see and inspect the books and records of the company
  • To file a lawsuit against the company for breach of fiduciary responsibility
  • To nominate directors (though minority safeguards make this difficult in practice) and suggest shareholder resolutions
  • To vote on the board of directors’ nominees for directors
  • To vote on mergers and corporate charter alterations
  • To receive dividends (in the case that they are announced)
  • To participate in yearly meetings in person or via teleconferences
  • To vote on important matters by proxy (if they are unable to attend voting meetings in person) either through mail-in ballots or digital voting platforms
  • To liquidate or sell the shares owned by them
  • To acquire the company’s newly issued shares
  • To vote on shareholder resolutions and to file them
  • To vote on proposed management styles

The rights described above can be divided into two categories: (1) cash-flow rights and (2) voting rights. While the cash-flow rights that come with shares, determine their value, voting rights may be significant as well.

Calculation Of The Value Of Cash-Flow Rights

Discounting future free cash flows can be used to calculate the value of shareholders’ cash-flow rights.

Calculation Of The Value Of Voting Rights

There are four ways to calculate the worth of a shareholder’s voting rights:

  • The distinction between voting and non-voting stock (dual-class approach)
  • The difference between the price paid in a block-trade transaction and the price paid in a subsequent exchange transaction (block-trade approach)
  • The implied voting value obtained from option prices
  • The excess lending fee over voting events

Role Of A Shareholder

Being a shareholder entails more than simply getting profits; it also entails certain duties. They are as follows:

  • Deciding about and determining what powers they will be provided to the company’s directors, such as electing and dismissing them from the position.
  • Setting a compensation for the directors. Shareholders must ensure that the sum given will cover the director’s cost of living in the city where he or she lives without jeopardizing the company’s finances.
  • Making decisions on matters over which the board of directors has no authority, such as modifications to the company’s constitution.
  • Examining the company’s financial accounts and approving them.

Shareholder VS Stakeholder

Many individuals mistakenly believe that shareholder and stakeholder are the same term. The terms, however, do not have the same meaning. A shareholder is a company’s owner based on the number of shares they possess. A stakeholder, unlike a shareholder, does not own a share of the company and yet is invested in its performance which may or may not be monetary in nature.

For example, a hotel chain in the United States has multiple stakeholders, including its employees, who rely on the company for their livelihood. Because of the taxes the company must pay each year, its stakeholders also include local and national governments.

Shareholder VS Subscriber

A company begins as a private limited company that is governed, founded, and structured by a group of people known as “subscribers” until becoming public. The subscribers are the company’s founding members, as their names appear in the memorandum of association. Their names are written in the public register after the firm goes public, and they remain there even if they leave the company.

Related Posts On The SimTrade Blog

▶ Anant JAIN Analysis Of “The Social Responsibility Of Business Is To Create Value For Stakeholders” Article By Freeman And Elms

▶ Anant JAIN Stakeholder

▶ Anant JAIN Mission Statement

▶ Anant JAIN Writing A Mission Statement

Useful Resources

Freeman E., H. Elms, 2018, The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Create Value for Stakeholders, MIT Sloan Management Review, 17/12/2020.

Jack Welch (2009) Welch condemns share price focus Financial Times.

About The Author

The article was written in August 2024 by Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2019-2022).

Key Expressions In The Article “The Social Responsibility Of Business Is To Create Value For Stakeholders” By Edward Freeman And Heather Elms

Key Expressions In The Article “The Social Responsibility Of Business Is To Create Value For Stakeholders” By Edward Freeman And Heather Elms

Anant Jain

In this article, Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2019-2022) defines the key expressions used in the article “The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Create Value for Stakeholders” written by Edward Freeman and Heather Elms in 2018.

Summary Of The Article

In the article “The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Create Value for Stakeholders”, Edward Freeman and Heather Elms (2018) argue against the statement made by Milton Friedman in a famous article published in The New York Times in 1970 that “The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Its Profits”. Friedman’s view corresponds to the traditional “Shareholder Approach”. Freeman and Elms state that businesses need to create value for all stakeholders (not only shareholders but also employees, customers, suppliers, communities, governments, etc.) if they want to be successful in the 21st century leading to the introduction of a new story: the “Stakeholder Approach”.

Key Expressions

We explain below key expressions to fully understand the article by Freeman and Elms: shareholders, stakeholders, corporate social responsibility, and mission statement.

Shareholders

A shareholder (also called stockholder) is a person, company, or institution that owns at least one share of a company’s stock called equity. The shareholders essentially own the company and therefore, reap the benefits of a business’s success. These benefits received may be in the form of the increase in the stock valuation or profits received as dividends. However, when a company incur losses, shareholders also incur them in the form of a decrease in the stock price or a decrease or absence in the dividends.

Stakeholders

Stakeholders are a group / party that are involved with a company and affect and/or are affected by the company’s action, either directly or indirectly. The main stakeholders for a typical company would include employees, customers, suppliers, and investors like shareholders and creditors. However, as corporate social responsibility has gained traction, the notion has been expanded to encompass communities, trade groups (trade unions and chambers of commerce for example), and governments.

Stakeholders can be of two different types: internal or external. Internal stakeholders are a group / party which are directly involved with a company and its business activities such as employees and investors. External stakeholders are a group / party which are indirectly affected by the company and its business activities and outcomes such as customers, suppliers, communities, and governments, and more broadly the environment and society.

Corporate Social Responsibility

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) is a type of self-regulatory business model that enables a company to be socially responsible towards itself, its stakeholders, the public and the environment. Companies can be aware of their impact on all aspects of society, including economic, social, and environmental, by practicing corporate social responsibility. Corporate social responsibility is a broad concept that varies depending on the company and industry. Businesses can benefit society while boosting their brands through CSR programs, corporate philanthropy, and volunteer efforts.

CSR is important for the communities, but it is also important for businesses themselves. Companies and its employees can indulge in CSR activities, that can help to form stronger bonds between the company and its employees. As a result, it can boost morale and make both employees and employers feel more connected to each other and the world around them.

Mission Statement

A mission statement explains company’s purpose of existence. A mission statement defines the company’s values, ethics, culture, goals, and agenda. In addition to this, a mission statement also entails how each and every component of a mission statement is applicable to the distinction stakeholders of a company including its employees, customers, suppliers, investors, and society at large.

A mission statement includes “What, How & Why” for a company i.e., what a company does, how it does it, and why it does it. It can be used by various stakeholders to assess if a company’s values and goals align with their own or not.

A mission statement would be unique and distinct for every company. A few examples of mission statement by popular companies are mentioned below:

  • Tesla: To accelerate the world’s transition to sustainable energy.
  • JP Morgan: To be the best financial services company in the world.
  • Starbucks: To inspire and nurture the human spirit—one person, one cup, and one neighbourhood at a time.
  • Nike: To expand human potential by creating ground-breaking sport innovations, by making our products more sustainably, by building a creative and diverse global team and by making a positive impact in communities where we live and work.

Related Posts On The SimTrade Blog

▶ Anant JAIN Analysis Of “The Social Responsibility Of Business Is To Create Value For Stakeholders” Article By Freeman And Elms

▶ Anant JAIN Stakeholder

▶ Anant JAIN Shareholder

▶ Anant JAIN Mission Statement

▶ Anant JAIN Writing A Mission Statement

Useful Resources

Freeman E., H. Elms, 2018, The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Create Value for Stakeholders, MIT Sloan Management Review, 17/12/2020.

Jack Welch (2009) Welch condemns share price focus Financial Times.

About The Author

The article was written in August 2024 by Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2019-2022).

Analysis Of “The Social Responsibility Of Business Is To Create Value For Stakeholders” Article By Freeman And Elms

Analysis Of “The Social Responsibility Of Business Is To Create Value For Stakeholders” Article By Freeman And Elms

Anant Jain

In this article, Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2019-2022) analyzes the article “The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Create Value for Stakeholders” written by Edward Freeman and Heather Elms in 2018.

Edward Freeman is a strategy, ethics, and entrepreneurship professor at the University of Virginia’s Darden School of Business. Heather Elms is an associate professor of international business at American University’s Kogod School of Business in Washington, D.C.

Summary

In the article “The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Create Value for Stakeholders”, Freeman and Elms (2018) argue against the statement made by Milton Friedman in a famous article published in The New York Times in 1970 that “The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Its Profits”. Friedman’s view corresponds to the traditional “Shareholder Approach”. Freeman and Elms state that businesses need to create value for all stakeholders (not only shareholders but also employees, customers, suppliers, communities, governments, etc.) if they want to be successful in the 21st century. This leads to the introduction of a new story: the “Stakeholder Approach”.

Reasons For A New Approach

Freeman and Elms explain the reasons for the need of a new story which are as follows:

  • They state that the Great Recession of the late 2000s made it abundantly clear the shareholder approach is no longer appropriate or applicable in today’s world. They explain it using the examples of companies (the investment bank Lehman Brothers and the automotive company General Motor) that got bankrupt/shutdown because they did not realize the need to switch from the shareholder approach to another approach.
  • They further refer to the former CEO of General Electric, Jack Welch, who stated in the Financial Times in 2009 that “Shareholder value is a result, not a strategy. Your main constituencies are your employees, your customers, and your products”.

Therefore, this new story, the Stakeholder Approach, spotlights stakeholders and not only shareholders.

  • In other words, stakeholders are interrelated and therefore interdependent on each other. Hence, the agenda for a business should be to create as much value as possible for all the stakeholders, which also includes creating profits for shareholders but is not limited to them.
  • Freeman and Elms state that “the winning business models of the 21st century figure out how to get these interests going in the same direction, with as few trade-offs as possible”. In other words, they mean that it is impossible to trade a stakeholders’ interest for another’s because someone else will figure out a way to do the same business without that trade-off. For example, Amazon, Genentech, Apple, and Google are all “high purpose stakeholder-oriented companies” i.e., they are focused on value creation for multiple stakeholders without compromising on any stakeholder.
  • Freeman and Elms state that worldwide, there are legal flexibility provided to companies to balance their stakeholders (including shareholders) in the interest of the business. In another sense, management’s role is to define, create and balance relationships with various stakeholders.

Freeman and Elms mention that businesses are driven to increase their demand (from customers).

  • However, “there are some activities in which business should not engage” to drive their demand. They explain the same using the example of business providing products at cheaper prices to the customers to drive their demand but at the cost of deprivation of value for their employees. In other words, the trade-off between stakeholders should not be opted for.
  • As a result, business will lead to the demand for new technological innovation. In a similar way, “business drives demand for responsible capitalism by offering responsible options for all its stakeholders”.
  • In addition to this, Freeman and Elms also mention that responsible capitalism is based on responsible behavior from stakeholders as well and not just the business. For example, customers should purchase responsible products, employees should choose to work for responsible employers, etc.

Freeman and Elms state that “business can be a part of solution to societal problems, rather than the cause”.

    • They use the example of Tesla, Renewable Energy, IBM and smart cities, and start-ups like Milk Stork (that provide an option for mothers who travel for business to get breast milk home to the children).
    • Freeman and Elms use this to explain to us the stakeholder approach and how the future of business and capitalism is related. They state that “capitalism is the greatest system of social cooperation that we have yet invented”. This is because it enables free people to cooperate and collaborate together and create value for one another in a way that no individual can do on their own.

To conclude, in their article, Freeman and Elms state and mention repetitively the need for existing and new companies (and their managers) to aspire to be a kind of business that creates value for all stakeholders without compromising on the value of one stakeholder to make some other stakeholders better off, to corporate and create value for one another.

Why Should I Be Interested In This Post?

This article should be read by management students or students from any other field to understand the importance of different stakeholders and how each stakeholder may be linked to one another. It will help them in the future when choosing an organization, either creating one from scratch or working as an employee for an organization, to align with the values of the organization and any stakeholder which may be important to them as well. This article can also we read by people currently employed or self-employed. It will help them to refresh their memories about the stakeholder approach and recheck if the current organization they are a part of align with their personal values or not. In general, this article will be helpful for anyone to briefly understand the stakeholder approach and how the importance of the stakeholder approach diverted from the shareholder approach and how useful and impactful it can be in today’s world.

Related Posts On The SimTrade Blog

   ▶ Anant JAIN Key Expressions In The Article “The Social Responsibility Of Business Is To Create Value For Stakeholders” By Edward Freeman And Heather Elms

   ▶ Anant JAIN Stakeholder

   ▶ Anant JAIN Shareholder

   ▶ Anant JAIN Mission Statement

   ▶ Anant JAIN Writing A Mission Statement

Useful Resources

Freeman E., H. Elms, 2018, The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Create Value for Stakeholders, MIT Sloan Management Review, 17/12/2020.

Jack Welch (2009) Welch condemns share price focus Financial Times.

About The Author

The article was written in August 2024 by Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2019-2022).

Acid-Test Ratio

Acid-Test Ratio

Anant Jain

In this article, Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2019-2022) explains how the Acid-Test Ratio can be used to assess the liquidity of company.

Introduction

The Acid-Test Ratio, also called the quick ratio or the acid ratio, is a liquidity ratio that determines if a company’s short-term assets are adequate to pay its short-term liabilities. Short-term liabilities can be debts (like bank debts) and commitments (like salaries). In other words, the acid-test ratio is a measure of a company’s ability to meet its financial obligations in the short term. There is a considerable danger of default if this is not accomplished.

Creditors regularly use the Acid-Test Ratio to assess their customers and borrowers, respectively. It may also be used by shareholders to determine if a company has enough cash to pay a dividend to its shareholders.

Calculation Of Acid-Test Ratio

To get a company’s acid test ratio, sum up all of its liquid assets, such as cash and cash equivalents along with its short-term investments such as marketable securities, as well as accounts receivable, and divide by the entire amount of current liabilities. On a company’s balance sheet, all of this information is listed as separate line items. On the balance sheet, the current liabilities amount is shown as a subtotal.

The acid-test ratio is calculated as follows:
Acid Test Ratio Formula 1

Where,

  • Cash and cash equivalents: company’s most liquid current assets, such as savings accounts, term deposits, and T-bills
  • Marketable securities: liquid financial instruments (like money market mutual funds) that may be easily turned into cash
  • Accounts receivables: funds owed to the company as a result of selling in credit products and/or services to customers
  • Current liabilities: debts and commitments that are due in the next 12 months:

Another method to calculate the numerator is to add up all current assets and exclude illiquid assets, such as inventory. As a result, the acid-test ratio formula can also be represented as follows:
Acid Test Ratio Formula 2
Where,

  • Current assets: assets that can be turned into cash in a year’s time
  • Inventory: value of goods and materials that a firm holds in order to sell to consumers
  • Current liabilities: debts and commitments that are due in the next 12 months

The argument behind this is that inventory is typically sluggish moving and hence difficult to convert into cash. Furthermore, if it needed to be turned into cash fast, it would most likely be sold at a significant discount to the balance sheet carrying cost. Other assets on a balance sheet, including advances to suppliers, prepayments, and deferred tax assets, etc., should be deducted if they cannot be utilized to fulfil liabilities in the short term.

Current Ratio VS Acid Test Ratio

Both the current ratio (also known as the working capital ratio) and the acid-test ratio calculates the capacity of a company to earn enough cash in the short term to pay off all of its current liabilities if they all came due at the same time. However, there are a few differences between both the ratios which are as follows:

  • The acid-test ratio, on the other hand, is regarded more cautious than the current ratio because it excludes assets like inventories, which might be difficult to liquidate rapidly.
  • Another distinguishing feature is that the current ratio considers assets that can be converted to cash in one year whereas the acid-test ratio only considers assets that can be converted to cash in 90 days or fewer.

Understanding Acid-Test Ratio

Analysts favor the acid-test ratio over the current ratio (also known as the working capital ratio) in some cases because the acid-test technique eliminates assets like inventories, which might be difficult to dispose rapidly. As a result, the acid test ratio is a more cautious and conservative measurement.

As a rule, the acid-test ratio should be higher than one such that the short-term assets cover the short-term liabilities. Companies having an acid-test ratio of less than one has insufficient liquid assets to cover their present liabilities and should be avoided. Moreover, if the acid-test ratio is significantly lower than the current ratio, a company’s current assets are heavily reliant on inventories.

This isn’t always a bad indicator, though, because certain company models are fundamentally inventory dependent. For example, retail stores may have extremely low acid-test ratios without being in a dire situation. The best acid-test ratio for a firm is determined by the industry and markets in which it works, the type of the company’s activity, and its overall financial health. For example, a low acid-test ratio is less important for a well-established company with long-term contract income or a company with excellent credit that can readily get short-term financing when needed. Usually, the acid-test ratio should be ideally greater than 1.

A high ratio, on the other hand, isn’t necessarily a positive thing. It might mean that money has accumulated and is sitting idle rather than being re-invested in productive use or returned to shareholders. Some IT corporations (like Apple) produce enormous cash flows, resulting in acid-test ratios much larger than one (up to 7 or 8). While this is definitely preferable than the alternative (an acid-test ratio less than one), activist investors who prefer that shareholders receive a piece of the earnings have criticized these corporations.

Drawbacks Of The Acid-Test Ratio

There are a number of drawbacks and limits and to utilize the acid-test ratio which are as follows:

  • The acid-test ratio alone is insufficient to identify the company’s liquidity condition. Other liquidity ratios, such as the current ratio or cash flow ratio, are frequently employed with the acid-test ratio to offer a more full and accurate picture of a company’s liquidity position.
  • Inventory is not included in the computation since it is not typically considered a liquid asset. Some firms, on the other hand, are able to sell their goods promptly and at a reasonable market price. In certain situations, the company’s inventory qualifies as an asset that can be turned into cash quickly.
  • The ratio does not include information on the timing and magnitude of cash flows, which are crucial in establishing a company’s capacity to meet its commitments on time.
  • The acid-test ratio presupposes that accounts receivable are easily and quickly collectible, although this isn’t always the case (due to delay of payments and bankruptcy of customers).

Conclusion

Acid-test ratio, also known as the quick ratio (as funds have to be quickly available on the assets side), determines whether a company has or can get sufficient cash to pay off its immediate liabilities, such as short-term debt. The acid-test ratio should be more than one. If it’s less than one, a company’s liquid assets are insufficient to cover its present liabilities, and it should be avoided. If the current ratio is significantly higher than the acid-test ratio, then it implies that a company’s current assets are heavily reliant on its inventory. A high acid-test ratio, on the other hand, may imply that cash has accumulated and is not being reinvested in productive use or returned to shareholders.

As a result, the ratio is most beneficial in scenarios where some assets, such as inventories, have fluctuating and uncertain liquidity. These goods may take a long time to convert to cash, thus they should not be compared to current liabilities. As a result, the ratio is frequently used to assess companies in industries that rely heavily on inventory, such as retail and manufacturing. It is less useful in service-based companies with substantial cash balances, such as Internet companies.

Useful Resources

Related Posts On The SimTrade Blog

About The Author

The article was written in August 2024 by Anant JAIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2019-2022).

My Internship Experience as a Strategy Consultant at Devlhon Consulting

My Internship Experience as a Strategy Consultant at Devlhon Consulting

 Mickael RUFFIN

In this article, Mickael RUFFIN (ESSEC Business School, Master in Strategy and Management of International Business (SMIB), 2023-2024) shares his professional experience as a Strategy Intern Consultant at Devlhon Consulting.

My Internship

My six-month internship in 2021 at Devlhon Consulting as a Strategy Consultant was a period filled with learning opportunities and stimulating challenges. From the onset, I was involved in high-value projects, for example, the reorganization of an north Africa ban’s branch network, allowing me to apply my strategic analysis skills and enhance company performance.

Logo of Devlhon Consulting.
Logo of Devlhon Consulting
Source: the company.

The Department

Devlhon Consulting’s Strategy Department focuses on providing strategic advisory services to improve client profitability and operational efficiency. The department handles a diverse range of projects, including market analysis, business restructuring, and financial performance improvement for various industries (for example, AXA, BNPP, Attijariwafa Bank,Dioul

My Missions

One of the most significant projects I undertook was conducting a strategic due diligence to enhance the profitability of a North African bank. This project allowed me to understand the nuances of African financial markets and develop actionable recommendations for improving the bank’s financial performance. Another key assignment was analyzing a Net-Zero banking tool for a French bank as part of its long-term strategic planning, which involved sustainability and green finance considerations. The tool was a software to be tested, allowing the bank to evaluate the carbon impact of the projects it was financing, with the aim of finding a balance between pollution and depollution.

Required Skills and Knowledge

The internship required a blend of technical and interpersonal skills. Technical skills included strategic analysis, financial modeling, and proficiency in data analysis tools (Power BI or Power Pivot and Dax). Interpersonal skills involved effective communication, teamwork, and the ability to present complex information clearly to clients and stakeholders.

What I Learned

I also contributed to the overhaul of a Cameroonian fintech’s business plan, similar to Lydia. By proposing practical adaptations, I helped the company strengthen its business model to better meet local market needs. These experiences enriched my professional journey, providing me with a global and strategic view of banking and financial operations, while developing essential skills in analysis and project management.

Financial Concepts Related to My Internship

Three financial concepts that were closely related to my internship at Devlhon Consulting include strategic due diligence, business model analysis, and sustainability in finance.

Strategic Due Diligence

Strategic due diligence was crucial for assessing the financial health and growth potential of the North African bank. This involved evaluating financial statements, market conditions, and competitive positioning to make informed recommendations. My role required meticulous analysis and strategic thinking to identify opportunities for profitability improvement.

Business Model Analysis

Analyzing the business model of the Cameroonian fintech required a deep understanding of financial structures, revenue streams, and market dynamics. I developed a comprehensive business plan that included financial projections and strategic initiatives to enhance the company’s competitive edge and market responsiveness.

Sustainability in Finance

The analysis of the Net-Zero banking tool involved integrating sustainability principles into financial planning. This concept focused on aligning banking practices with environmental goals, such as reducing carbon footprints and promoting green investments. My work contributed to developing strategies that balanced financial performance with sustainability objectives.

Why should I be interested in this post?

This position provides an overview of the various professions and actors in the finance sector, especially in FIG (Financial Institutions Group). It is a good first internship to discover a wide range of careers.

Related posts on the SimTrade blog

   ▶ All posts about Professional experiences

   ▶ Alexandre VERLET Classic brain teasers from real-life interviews

Useful resources

Company Website

Recruitment Platform

About the author

The article was written in August 2024 by Mickael RUFFIN (ESSEC Business School, Master in Strategy and Management of International Business (SMIB), 2023-2024) .

My Internship Experience as a Structured Finance Analyst at Société Générale

My Internship Experience as a Structured Finance Analyst at Société Générale

 Mickael RUFFIN

In this article, Mickael RUFFIN (ESSEC Business School, Master in Strategy and Management of International Business (SMIB), 2023-2024) shares his professional experience as a Structured Finance Analyst Intern at Société Générale.

My Internship

During my one-year apprenticeship at Société Générale CIB, I had the opportunity to work as a Structured Finance Analyst within the S&E (Sanction & Embargo) team. This experience was a crucial step in my career, providing me with an in-depth understanding of the complex dynamics of finance within the context of international sanctions and economic embargoes.

Logo of Société Générale CIB.
Logo of Société Générale CIB
Source: the company.

The Department

The S&E team at Société Générale is responsible for managing the bank’s activities in regions affected (Sanction Country.png) by international sanctions and embargoes. This includes ensuring compliance with legal and regulatory requirements, assessing the risks associated with operating in these areas, and structuring financial solutions that adhere to these constraints.

Sanction Country.
Sanction Country
Source: GAO.

My Missions

My primary role involved assisting with the financial structuring for French firms operating in sanctioned and embargoed regions. I quickly grasped the importance of meticulous risk assessment and financial modeling to ensure the success of projects in these restrictive environments. One of my significant achievements was modeling joint-venture finance in the oil and gas sector, a project that required a precise understanding of investment risks and international sanction regulations.

Required Skills and Knowledge

This internship required a combination of soft and hard skills. On the technical side, I needed strong financial modeling capabilities, an understanding of international sanctions law, and proficiency in data analysis tools. Soft skills included effective communication, especially when presenting complex financial models to the executive committee, and strong problem-solving abilities to navigate the challenges posed by operating in high-risk regions.

What I Learned

One of the most rewarding aspects of this internship was leading comprehensive due diligence processes for significant capital investments. For example, I conducted a thorough due diligence for a $300 million capital expenditure acquisition for a defense entity operating in an embargoed region. This project enhanced my data analysis skills and regulatory compliance knowledge. Presenting these models and projects to the executive committee for strategic review enriched my ability to communicate complex financial information clearly and persuasively.

Financial Concepts Related to My Internship

Three financial concepts were particularly relevant during my internship: risk assessment, financial structuring, and due diligence.

Risk Assessment

Risk assessment was crucial in evaluating the feasibility of financial projects in sanctioned regions. This involved analyzing political and economic conditions, understanding legal constraints, and forecasting potential financial impacts. My role required me to develop comprehensive risk assessment models that informed strategic decision-making.

Financial Structuring

Financial structuring involved designing financial solutions that complied with international sanctions while meeting the needs of our clients. This required a deep understanding of financial instruments and regulatory frameworks. I was responsible for creating financial models that balanced risk and return, ensuring compliance and profitability.

Due Diligence

Due diligence was a critical part of my responsibilities, involving thorough investigations into potential investments to ensure they met all regulatory and financial criteria. This process included financial analysis, risk evaluation, and legal compliance checks. My experience in conducting due diligence for large-scale acquisitions honed my analytical skills and attention to detail.

Why should I be interested in this post?

This experience can be very interesting if you want to work either in investment banking or at the Ministry of Finance or Economy. This position combines financial technicality and the importance of understanding geopolitical issues related to the strategies of major French companies.

Related posts on the SimTrade blog

   ▶ All posts about Professional experiences

   ▶ Alexandre VERLET Classic brain teasers from real-life interviews

Useful resources

SG CIB Website

About the author

The article was written in August 2024 by Mickael RUFFIN (ESSEC Business School, Master in Strategy and Management of International Business (SMIB), 2023-2024) .

Litecoin: Analysis of the Pioneering Cryptocurrency’s Impact on Digital Finance

 Snehasish CHINARA

In this article, Snehasish CHINARA (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole Program – Master in Management, 2022-2024) explains cryptocurrency Litecoin, shedding light on its impact and value propositions for digital finance.

Historical context and background

Litecoin, often referred to as the “silver to Bitcoin’s gold,” emerged in 2011 as one of the earliest altcoins, or alternative cryptocurrencies, following the launch of Bitcoin in 2009. It was created by Charlie Lee, a former Google engineer and Coinbase employee. Lee designed Litecoin with the intention of addressing some of the perceived limitations of Bitcoin, such as transaction speed and scalability.

One of the key innovations of Litecoin was its adoption of the Scrypt hashing algorithm instead of Bitcoin’s SHA-256 algorithm. This choice made Litecoin more accessible to individual miners using consumer-grade hardware, as it reduced the advantage of specialized mining equipment known as ASICs (Application-Specific Integrated Circuits). As a result, Litecoin initially gained popularity among miners and enthusiasts who sought a more democratic and decentralized mining ecosystem.

Litecoin also introduced a faster block generation time compared to Bitcoin, with new blocks being created approximately every 2.5 minutes instead of every 10 minutes. This faster block time enabled quicker transaction confirmations, making Litecoin more suitable for everyday transactions.

Over the years, Litecoin has established itself as one of the most prominent cryptocurrencies in the market, often considered a reliable and stable digital asset. Its longevity and consistent development have contributed to its reputation as a credible alternative to Bitcoin.

Litecoin’s journey has been marked by various milestones, including network upgrades, partnerships, and integrations into payment systems and exchanges. Despite facing competition from other cryptocurrencies and undergoing market fluctuations, Litecoin has maintained a strong community of supporters and continues to be actively traded and utilized for various purposes, including payments, remittances, and investment.

Litecoin Logo

Source: Litecoin

Figure 1. Key Dates in Litecoin History

Source: Yahoo! Finance.

Key features

    Scrypt Algorithm

    Unlike Bitcoin’s SHA-256 algorithm, Litecoin utilizes the Scrypt hashing algorithm for its proof-of-work consensus mechanism. This algorithm was chosen to enable faster block generation and to promote more decentralized mining by reducing the advantage of specialized mining hardware (Application-Specific Integrated Circuits (ASIC) versus consumer-grade hardware like standard PCs).

    Faster Block Time

    Litecoin has a target block time of approximately 2.5 minutes, compared to Bitcoin’s 10 minutes. This faster block time allows for quicker transaction confirmations, making Litecoin more suitable for everyday transactions.

    Higher Maximum Coin Supply

    Litecoin has a maximum coin supply limit of 84 million coins, four times the maximum supply of Bitcoin. This larger supply aims to facilitate more widespread adoption and usage while still maintaining scarcity.

    Segregated Witness (SegWit) Activation

    Litecoin was one of the first major cryptocurrencies to activate Segregated Witness (SegWit), a protocol upgrade aimed at improving transaction throughput and scalability. SegWit also paved the way for the implementation of the Lightning Network on Litecoin, enabling off-chain transactions for faster and cheaper payments.

    Atomic Swaps

    Litecoin has been at the forefront of implementing Atomic Swaps, a technology that allows for the trustless exchange of cryptocurrencies across different blockchains without the need for intermediaries like crypto platforms. This feature enhances interoperability and decentralization within the cryptocurrency ecosystem.

    Litecoin Improvement Proposals (LIPs)

    Similar to Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs), Litecoin has its own proposal system called Litecoin Improvement Proposals (LIPs). These proposals allow community members to suggest changes or improvements to the Litecoin protocol, fostering a transparent and collaborative development process.

Use cases

    Peer-to-Peer Payments

    Litecoin’s fast transaction confirmations and low fees make it suitable for peer-to-peer transactions. Users can quickly send and receive funds across the globe without relying on traditional banking systems, making Litecoin an efficient option for remittances and international payments.

    Online Purchases

    As of 2023, over 2,000 online merchants and service providers accept Litecoin as a form of payment globally. Litecoin’s transaction volume has steadily increased, with an average of over 100,000 transactions per day. In 2022, Litecoin processed over 35 million transactions, highlighting its growing use for everyday payments. Many online merchants and service providers accept Litecoin as a form of payment. There are over 5,000 cryptocurrency ATMs worldwide that support Litecoin, allowing users to buy and sell LTC with cash. Users can use Litecoin to purchase a wide range of goods and services, including electronics, clothing, digital products, and more.

    Micropayments

    Litecoin’s low transaction fees and fast processing times make it well-suited for micropayments, enabling users to make small transactions economically. This use case is particularly relevant for content creators, online tipping, and pay-per-view services.

    Cross-Border Transactions

    Litecoin’s borderless nature makes it an attractive option for cross-border transactions, as users can avoid the high fees and long processing times associated with traditional remittance services and bank transfers.

    Privacy Transactions

    While not as focused on privacy as some other cryptocurrencies like Monero or Zcash, Litecoin offers a degree of privacy through features like confidential transactions and the option to use privacy-enhancing wallets. This makes Litecoin appealing for users who prioritize privacy in their transactions.

Technology and underlying blockchain

Litecoin operates on a blockchain-based decentralized network, sharing many similarities with Bitcoin while incorporating several key technical differences. At its core, Litecoin’s blockchain serves as a distributed ledger that records all transactions made with its native cryptocurrency, LTC. One of the distinguishing features of Litecoin is its utilization of the Scrypt proof-of-work algorithm, which differs from Bitcoin’s SHA-256 algorithm. This algorithm was chosen to promote a more equitable mining process, allowing individuals to mine LTC using consumer-grade hardware and reducing the dominance of specialized mining equipment.

The Litecoin blockchain maintains a target block time of approximately 2.5 minutes, significantly faster than Bitcoin’s 10-minute block time. This faster block generation rate enables quicker transaction confirmations, making Litecoin well-suited for use in everyday transactions and enhancing its scalability. Additionally, Litecoin implemented Segregated Witness (SegWit) in 2017, a protocol upgrade aimed at improving transaction throughput and reducing network congestion by separating transaction signatures from transaction data.

Furthermore, Litecoin has experimented with technologies like the Lightning Network, a layer-2 scaling solution designed to facilitate instant and low-cost transactions by leveraging payment channels. This technology enables off-chain transactions that can be settled on the Litecoin blockchain, further enhancing its transaction speed and efficiency.

Supply of coins

Figure Figure 2. Litecoin Supply

Source: Yahoo! Finance.

Litecoin’s coin supply is governed by its protocol, which dictates the issuance rate and maximum supply limit. Unlike traditional fiat currencies that are subject to centralized control by governments and central banks, Litecoin operates on a decentralized network secured by blockchain technology. The issuance of new Litecoin coins occurs through a process called mining, where miners use computational power to validate transactions and add new blocks to the blockchain.

Litecoin employs a deflationary monetary policy, with a fixed issuance schedule that halves the block reward approximately every four years. Initially, the block reward was set at 50 Litecoins per block, but it reduces by half every 840,000 blocks. This process, known as “halving,” aims to curb inflation over time and maintain scarcity, similar to Bitcoin’s issuance schedule. As of now, the block reward stands at 12.5 Litecoins per block, and this rate will continue to halve periodically until the maximum supply of 84 million Litecoins is reached.

The predictable issuance schedule and maximum supply cap of Litecoin contribute to its scarcity and value proposition, aligning with principles of sound money and monetary decentralization. This transparent and algorithmic approach to coin issuance fosters confidence among users and investors, as it prevents arbitrary inflation and ensures the integrity of Litecoin’s monetary policy over the long term.

Historical data for Litecoin

How to get the data?

The Litecoin is popular cryptocurrency on the market, and historical data for the Litecoin such as prices and volume traded can be easily downloaded from the internet sources such as Yahoo! Finance, Blockchain.com & CoinMarketCap. For example, you can download data for Litecoin on Yahoo! Finance (the Yahoo! code for Litecoin is LTC-USD).

Figure Figure 3. Litecoin data

Source: Yahoo! Finance.

Historical data for the Litecoin market prices

Since its inception in 2011, Litecoin has undergone multiple bull and bear cycles, with its price witnessing remarkable volatility. In its early years, Litecoin’s market price remained relatively low, often trading at a fraction of Bitcoin’s value. However, as the cryptocurrency market gained traction and Litecoin’s utility as a fast and affordable payment method became recognized, its price began to appreciate steadily. The price of Litecoin experienced its first major surge in late 2013, reaching an all-time high above $50 USD. This rally was fueled by increased adoption, media attention, and speculation within the cryptocurrency community.

Following the 2013 peak, Litecoin underwent a prolonged bear market, with its price declining significantly over the subsequent years. However, Litecoin’s resilience and active development continued to attract interest, leading to periodic price rallies and subsequent corrections. The cryptocurrency market’s overall volatility, regulatory uncertainty, and competition from other digital assets also influenced Litecoin’s price movements during this period.

One of the most significant price rallies in Litecoin’s history occurred during the cryptocurrency bull market of 2017-2018. During this period, Litecoin’s price surged to unprecedented levels, reaching an all-time high of over $300 USD in December 2017. This rally was fueled by factors such as increased mainstream adoption, the integration of Segregated Witness (SegWit) and the Lightning Network, and speculative buying spurred by the broader cryptocurrency market rally.

Since the 2017-2018 bull market, Litecoin has experienced periods of both consolidation and volatility. While its price has not reached the same highs as during the peak of the bull market, Litecoin has maintained a relatively stable position within the cryptocurrency market, often regarded as one of the top digital assets by market capitalization. The ongoing development of Litecoin’s protocol, partnerships, and adoption efforts continue to shape its market prices, as investors and enthusiasts closely monitor its evolution in the broader cryptocurrency landscape.

Figure 4 below represents the evolution of the price of Litecoin in US dollar over the period September 2014 – May 2024. The price corresponds to the “closing” price (observed at 10:00 PM CET at the end of the month).

Figure 4. Evolution of Litecoin price

Source: Yahoo! Finance.

R program

The R program below written by Shengyu ZHENG allows you to download the data from Yahoo! Finance website and to compute summary statistics and risk measures about the Litecoin.

Download R file

Data file

The R program that you can download above allows you to download the data for the Litecoin from the Yahoo! Finance website. The database starts on September 2014.

Table 1 below represents the top of the data file for the Litecoin downloaded from the Yahoo! Finance website with the R program.

Table 1. Top of the data file for the Litecoin

Source: computation by the author (data: Yahoo! Finance website).

Python code

You can download the Python code used to download the data from Yahoo! Finance.

Download the Python code for USD Coin data

Python script to download Litecoin historical data and save it to an Excel sheet:

import yfinance as yf

import pandas as pd

# Define the ticker symbol for Cardano “ADA-USD”

Litecoin_ticker = “LTC-USD”

# Define the date range for historical data

start_date = “2014-09-01”

end_date = “2024-04-30”

# Download historical data using yfinance

CLitecoin_data = yf.download(Litecoin_ticker, start=start_date, end=end_date)

# Create a Pandas DataFrame from the downloaded data

Litecoin_df = pd.DataFrame(Litecoin_data)

# Define the Excel file path

excel_file_path = ” Litecoin_historical_data.xlsx”

# Save the data to an Excel sheet

Litecoin_df.to_excel(excel_file_path, sheet_name=”Litecoin Historical Data”)

print(f”Data saved to {excel_file_path}”)

# Make sure you have the required libraries installed and adjust the “start_date” and “end_date” variables to the desired date range for the historical data you want to download.

Evolution of the Litecoin

Figure 5 below gives the evolution of the Litecoin on a daily basis.

Figure 5. Evolution of the Litecoin

Source: computation by the author (data: Yahoo! Finance website).

Figure 6 below gives the evolution of the Litecoin returns from September 2014 to May 2024 on a daily basis.

Figure 6. Evolution of the Litecoin returns.

Source: computation by the author (data: Yahoo! Finance website).

The R program that you can download above also allows you to compute summary statistics about the returns of the Litecoin.

Table 2 below presents the following summary statistics estimated for the Litecoin:

  • The mean
  • The standard deviation (the squared root of the variance)
  • The skewness
  • The kurtosis.

The mean, the standard deviation / variance, the skewness, and the kurtosis refer to the first, second, third and fourth moments of statistical distribution of returns respectively.

Table 2. Summary statistics for Litecoin

Source: computation by the author (data: Yahoo! Finance website).

Statistical distribution of the Litecoin returns

Historical distribution

Figure 7 represents the historical distribution of the Litecoin daily returns for the period from September 2014 to May 2024.

Figure 7. Historical distribution of Litecoin returns.

Source: computation by the author (data: Yahoo! Finance website).

Gaussian distribution

The Gaussian distribution (also called the normal distribution) is a parametric distribution with two parameters: the mean and the standard deviation of returns. We estimated these two parameters over the period from September 2014 to May 2024.

Figure 9 below represents the Gaussian distribution of the Litecoin daily returns with parameters estimated over the period from September 2014 to May 2024.

Figure 8. Gaussian distribution of the Litecoin returns.

Source: computation by the author (data: Yahoo! Finance website).

Risk measures of the Litecoin returns

The R program that you can download above also allows you to compute risk measures about the returns of the Litecoin.

Table 3 below presents the following risk measures estimated for the Litecoin:

  • The long-term volatility (the unconditional standard deviation estimated over the entire period)
  • The short-term volatility (the standard deviation estimated over the last three months)
  • The Value at Risk (VaR) for the left tail (the 5% quantile of the historical distribution)
  • The Value at Risk (VaR) for the right tail (the 95% quantile of the historical distribution)
  • The Expected Shortfall (ES) for the left tail (the average loss over the 5% quantile of the historical distribution)
  • The Expected Shortfall (ES) for the right tail (the average loss over the 95% quantile of the historical distribution)
  • The Stress Value (SV) for the left tail (the 1% quantile of the tail distribution estimated with a Generalized Pareto distribution)
  • The Stress Value (SV) for the right tail (the 99% quantile of the tail distribution estimated with a Generalized Pareto distribution)

Table 3. Risk measures for the Litecoin

Source: computation by the author (data: Yahoo! Finance website).

The volatility is a global measure of risk as it considers all the returns. The Value at Risk (VaR), Expected Shortfall (ES) and Stress Value (SV) are local measures of risk as they focus on the tails of the distribution. The study of the left tail is relevant for an investor holding a long position in the Litecoin while the study of the right tail is relevant for an investor holding a short position in the Litecoin.

Why should I be interested in this post?

This blog offers an intriguing journey into the world of Litecoin, tailored for both newcomers and seasoned cryptocurrency enthusiasts alike. It unveils the innovative features and unique characteristics that set Litecoin apart in the digital currency landscape. From its inception to its current standing, we explore Litecoin’s historical journey, shedding light on its pivotal moments and market dynamics. Whether you’re intrigued by its faster block time or its active development community, this post provides a comprehensive understanding of Litecoin’s significance and potential. Whether you’re a curious observer or an investor seeking new opportunities, join us as we delve into the fascinating world of Litecoin and uncover its role in shaping the future of decentralized finance.

Related posts on the SimTrade blog

About cryptocurrencies

   ▶ Snehasish CHINARA Bitcoin: the mother of all cryptocurrencies

   ▶ Snehasish CHINARA How to get crypto data

   ▶ Alexandre VERLET Cryptocurrencies

About statistics

   ▶ Shengyu ZHENG Moments de la distribution

   ▶ Shengyu ZHENG Mesures de risques

   ▶ Jayati WALIA Returns

Useful resources

Academic research about risk

Longin F. (2000) From VaR to stress testing: the extreme value approach Journal of Banking and Finance, N°24, pp 1097-1130.

Longin F. (2016) Extreme events in finance: a handbook of extreme value theory and its applications Wiley Editions.

Data

Yahoo! Finance

Yahoo! Finance Historical data for Litecoin

CoinMarketCap Historical data for Litecoin

About the author

The article was written in July 2024 by Snehasish CHINARA (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole Program – Master in Management, 2022-2024).

Investissements Durables : Le Nouveau Visage de la Finance

Investissements Durables : Le Nouveau Visage de la Finance

Eya FARHOUD

Dans cet article, (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2023-2026) explore le nouveau visage de la finance avec les investissements durables.

Introduction

Dans un monde où les enjeux environnementaux, sociaux et de gouvernance (ESG) prennent une place de plus en plus prépondérante, les investissements durables émergent comme une alternative de choix sur les marchés financiers. Cette tendance, autrefois marginale, gagne désormais en popularité et en influence, offrant aux investisseurs la possibilité de concilier rentabilité financière et impact positif sur la société et l’environnement.

Qu’est-ce que les investissements durables ? Les investissements durables, également connus sous le nom d’investissements socialement responsables (ISR) ou d’investissements à impact, consistent à allouer des fonds à des entreprises et des projets qui intègrent des critères ESG dans leur stratégie et leur gouvernance. Ces critères peuvent inclure la réduction des émissions de carbone, la promotion de la diversité et de l’inclusion, ou encore le respect des droits de l’homme.

Les avantages des investissements durables

Les investissements durables offrent plusieurs avantages tant aux investisseurs qu’à la société dans son ensemble. Sur le plan financier, de nombreuses études ont montré que les entreprises qui intègrent des pratiques durables tendent à être plus résilientes et à générer des rendements financiers supérieurs à long terme. De plus, investir dans des entreprises qui contribuent positivement à la société et à l’environnement peut être source de satisfaction morale pour les investisseurs, qui voient leur argent travailler en faveur d’un monde meilleur.

L’essor de l’investissement durable

Au cours des dernières années, l’investissement durable a connu une croissance exponentielle, attirant l’attention des investisseurs institutionnels, des fonds de pension et même des particuliers. Les actifs sous gestion intégrant des critères ESG ont atteint des niveaux record, témoignant de l’engagement croissant en faveur d’une finance plus responsable et éthique.

Les défis et les opportunités

Malgré son essor rapide, l’investissement durable fait face à plusieurs défis, notamment celui de la standardisation des critères ESG et de la mesure de l’impact réel des investissements. Cependant, ces défis sont également source d’opportunités, d’innovation et de progrès dans le domaine de la finance durable.

Articles connexes sur le blog SimTrade

   ▶ Anant JAIN Dow Jones Sustainability Index

   ▶ Anant JAIN The World 10 Most Sustainable Companies in 2021

Ressources utiles

Muriel Motte (29/01/2024) Les Américains désertent les fonds d’investissement durables, L’opinion.

A propos de l’auteur

Cet article a été écrit en Avril 2024 par Eya FARHOUD (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2023-2026).

Le règne des Algorithmes de Trading Haute Fréquence : Bénéfices et Risques

Le règne des Algorithmes de Trading Haute Fréquence : Bénéfices et Risques

Eya FARHOUD

Dans cet article, Eya FARHOUD (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2023-2026) explique les bénéfices et risques du Trading Haute Fréquence (THF).

Introduction

Depuis les dernières décennies, les marchés financiers ont été témoins d’une révolution silencieuse mais omniprésente : l’avènement des algorithmes de trading haute fréquence (THF) ou High Frequency Trading (HFT). Ces systèmes informatiques ultra-rapides sont devenus des acteurs majeurs sur les marchés mondiaux, modifiant profondément la dynamique traditionnelle du trading et suscitant à la fois admiration et inquiétude.

Qu’est-ce que le trading haute fréquence ? Le THF est une méthode de négociation qui utilise des algorithmes informatiques pour exécuter un grand nombre d’ordres à des vitesses extrêmement élevées. Ces algorithmes analysent en temps réel les données du marché, prennent des décisions d’achat ou de vente et exécutent les transactions en une fraction de seconde, parfois même en microsecondes. Selon un rapport publié en 2023 par la Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), le trading haute fréquence représentait environ 50% et 60% des transactions sur les marchés boursiers américains.

Les avantages du trading haute fréquence

Les partisans du trading haute fréquence mettent en avant plusieurs avantages de cette approche. Tout d’abord, la vitesse. Les algorithmes HFT permettent aux traders de saisir les opportunités de marché en temps réel, exploitant les écarts de prix minuscules qui peuvent survenir en l’espace de quelques millisecondes. Ensuite, l’efficacité. Les transactions étant automatisées, le trading haute fréquence permet de réduire les coûts de transaction et d’optimiser l’exécution des ordres. Plus concrètement, selon une étude de la Banque Centrale Européenne, le THF a contribué à réduire les coûts de transaction de l’ordre de 5 à 10 % sur les marchés européens entre 2015 et 2020.

Les défis et les risques

Cependant, le trading haute fréquence n’est pas sans ses critiques et ses risques. L’un des principaux défis est lié à la volatilité. La nature ultra-rapide du trading HFT peut parfois amplifier les mouvements de marché, créant des flash crashes et des situations de panique. Il existe également des préoccupations concernant l’équité et la transparence du marché, certains accusant les traders haute fréquence de bénéficier d’un accès privilégié à l’information et de manipuler les marchés à leur avantage.

La réglementation et l’avenir du trading haute fréquence

Face à ces défis, les régulateurs financiers du monde entier ont commencé à prendre des mesures pour encadrer le trading haute fréquence. Aux États-Unis, par exemple, la SEC a adopté des règles visant à améliorer la transparence et la surveillance des marchés, notamment en imposant des obligations de reporting plus strictes pour les opérations effectuées par les traders haute fréquence. Malgré ces préoccupations et réglementations, le trading haute fréquence continue de prospérer et d’évoluer. Les avancées technologiques telles que l’intelligence artificielle et le machine learning promettent de rendre les algorithmes encore plus sophistiqués et réactifs aux conditions du marché. L’avenir du trading haute fréquence reste donc incertain, mais une chose est sûre : son impact sur les marchés financiers continuera d’être au cœur des débats et des discussions pour les années à venir.

Articles connexes sur le blog SimTrade

   ▶ Akshit GUPTA High-frequency trading

   ▶ Clara PINTO High-frequency trading and limit orders

   ▶ Shruti CHAND High-frequency trading: pros and cons

Ressources utiles

Luc Goupil (2013) Trading à haute fréquence : empreinte de marché et enjeux de régulation Revue d’économie financière 110, 277-294.

A propos de l’auteure

Cet article a été écrit en Juillet 2024 par Eya FARHOUD (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2023-2026).

Une journée dans la vie d’un stagiaire en Middle Office

Une journée dans la vie d’un stagiaire en Middle Office

Esten CHAUVIN

Dans cet article, Esten CHAUVIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2023-2026) partage son expérience sur ce qu’implique une journée typique en tant que stagiaire en Middle Office. Cet article est destiné aux étudiants de gestion (universités, écoles de commerce) qui vont commencer leur premier stage en finance de marché.

Introduction

Le Middle Office joue un rôle crucial dans les institutions financières, assurant la liaison entre le Front Office et le Back Office. Si vous êtes curieux de savoir à quoi ressemble une journée type en tant que stagiaire en Middle Office, cet article est pour vous. Je vais vous emmener à travers une journée ordinaire, de l’arrivée matinale aux derniers instants avant de partir.

Matinée

Arrivée et préparation (7h30 – 8h)

Je commence ma journée tôt, généralement entre 7h30 et 8h00. Après avoir pris un café pour bien démarrer la journée, je commence par vérifier mes emails et prendre note des tâches prioritaires. Cette première étape est cruciale pour organiser ma journée efficacement. Les marchés européens ouvrent à 9h00, il est donc important d’être prêt avant l’ouverture pour réagir rapidement aux événements de la nuit.

Revue des positions et des expositions (8h – 9h)

La première tâche de la journée consiste à revoir les positions de la veille. Cela inclut l’examen des transactions effectuées et des positions détenues en fin de journée pour s’assurer qu’elles sont conformes aux attentes et aux stratégies définies. Je vérifie les expositions aux risques, c’est-à-dire l’ampleur de nos investissements dans différentes classes d’actifs, et identifie toute anomalie ou écart. Par exemple, une anomalie pourrait être une transaction non enregistrée correctement ou une position de change qui ne correspond pas aux prévisions initiales en raison d’une erreur de saisie ou d’une fluctuation imprévue des taux de change. Cette vérification matinale permet de détecter rapidement tout problème potentiel et de les résoudre en collaboration avec le Front Office. Par exemple, un écart significatif dans les expositions de change pourrait nécessiter une action immédiate, comme ajuster des positions ou couvrir des risques, avant l’ouverture du marché pour éviter des impacts négatifs.

Réunions du matin (9h – 10h)

Ensuite, je participe à une réunion d’équipe pour discuter des priorités de la journée. Ces réunions sont l’occasion de partager des mises à jour sur les nouvelles régulations ou les événements de marché récents. Par exemple, pendant mon stage chez Oddo BHF, nous avons discuté des implications des fluctuations du marché des changes sur nos portefeuilles. Ces réunions permettent également de coordonner les efforts entre les différents membres de l’équipe pour s’assurer que toutes les tâches critiques sont couvertes.

Traitement des transactions (10h – 12h)

Après la réunion, je me plonge dans le traitement des transactions. Cela implique la confirmation et la validation des transactions effectuées par le Front Office. J’utilise des systèmes internes pour saisir et valider les données. Par exemple, traiter une transaction complexe impliquant des dérivés OTC peut être un véritable défi, mais c’est aussi une excellente occasion d’apprendre. Il est essentiel de vérifier que toutes les transactions sont correctement enregistrées et conformes aux régulations en vigueur.

Après-midi

Gestion des risques (13h – 15h)

L’après-midi est souvent consacrée à la gestion des risques. Je surveille les expositions aux risques de marché, de crédit et de liquidité. Utiliser des modèles quantitatifs pour évaluer les risques fait partie de mon quotidien. Un exemple concret est l’ajustement des marges suite à une volatilité accrue du marché. Il est crucial de réagir rapidement aux changements de marché pour minimiser les risques potentiels.

Interaction avec d’autres départements (15h – 16h)

La collaboration est essentielle en Middle Office. Je travaille régulièrement avec le Back Office pour le règlement des transactions et avec le département de compliance pour s’assurer de la conformité des transactions. Par exemple, il m’est arrivé de coordonner avec le service IT pour résoudre un problème technique urgent. Ces interactions permettent de s’assurer que les opérations se déroulent sans accroc et que toutes les parties prenantes sont alignées.

Analyse et reporting (16h – 18h)

Une partie importante de mon travail consiste à préparer des rapports pour la direction et les régulateurs. Cela inclut l’analyse des performances des portefeuilles et des stratégies de couverture. Pendant mon stage, j’ai par exemple présenté un rapport hebdomadaire sur les risques de marché à l’équipe de gestion, ce qui m’a permis de développer mes compétences en communication et en analyse. Les rapports doivent être précis et fournir une vue claire des risques et des opportunités.

Fin de journée

Suivi des tâches en cours (18h – 18h30)

En fin de journée, je vérifie les tâches accomplies et prépare celles pour le lendemain. Cela inclut de répondre aux emails de dernière minute et de suivre les points en suspens. Clôturer une transaction en suspens avec une contrepartie internationale peut être un défi, mais c’est aussi très gratifiant. Il est important de s’assurer que toutes les tâches critiques sont traitées avant de quitter le bureau.

Réunion de fin de journée (18h30 – 19h)

Nous terminons souvent la journée par un bilan avec l’équipe. Ces réunions sont l’occasion de discuter des défis rencontrés et des solutions apportées. Par exemple, partager les leçons apprises suite à un incident de marché imprévu est une excellente façon d’améliorer continuellement nos processus. Ces réunions permettent également de s’assurer que tout le monde est aligné pour les tâches du lendemain.

Départ (19h)

Je pars généralement après 19h. Avant de partir, je prends un moment pour réfléchir aux tâches prioritaires et aux objectifs à court terme pour le lendemain. Cette réflexion aide à rester organisé et prêt pour la journée suivante.

Conclusion

Chaque journée en Middle Office est unique, remplie de défis et d’opportunités d’apprentissage. En tant que stagiaire, vous serez au cœur de l’action, travaillant en étroite collaboration avec différents départements pour assurer le bon fonctionnement de l’institution. L’organisation, la gestion du temps et la capacité à collaborer efficacement sont des compétences clés que vous développerez.

Conseils pour les futurs stagiaires

  • Organisation et gestion du temps : Planifiez votre journée et priorisez vos tâches.
  • Communication : Développez des compétences en communication pour interagir efficacement avec les différents départements.
  • Apprentissage continu : Restez curieux et cherchez constamment à apprendre et à vous améliorer.

Ressources utiles

Gestionnaire Middle Office par ABC Bourse (2023)

Middle Office par Philip Lawton (2012)

À propos de l’auteur

Cet article a été écrit en juillet 2024 par Esten CHAUVIN, étudiant en Master de Management à l’ESSEC Business School, ancien stagiaire OTC Derivatives, Stock Loans, Repo Loans chez Oddo BHF.

Introduction aux produits dérivés de gré à gré (OTC Derivatives)

Introduction aux produits dérivés de gré à gré (OTC Derivatives)

Esten CHAUVIN

Dans cet article, Esten CHAUVIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2023-2026) partage son expérience et ses connaissances sur les produits dérivés de gré à gré (OTC Derivatives), leur fonctionnement et leurs applications en finance de marché.

Introduction

Les produits dérivés de gré à gré (OTC Derivatives) sont des instruments financiers négociés directement entre deux parties, sans passer par une bourse. OTC signifie “Over-The-Counter”, indiquant que ces transactions se font en dehors des marchés réglementés. Ces produits jouent un rôle crucial dans la gestion des risques financiers et l’optimisation des portefeuilles d’investissement. Cet article vise à introduire les concepts fondamentaux des produits dérivés OTC et à expliquer leur importance dans les marchés financiers.

Fonctionnement des produits dérivés OTC

Les produits dérivés OTC incluent une variété d’instruments tels que les swaps, les forwards et les options. Contrairement aux dérivés échangés en bourse, les dérivés OTC sont personnalisés en fonction des besoins spécifiques des parties impliquées. Par exemple, une entreprise peut utiliser un swap de taux d’intérêt pour échanger des paiements d’intérêts à taux fixe contre des paiements à taux variable afin de mieux correspondre à ses flux de trésorerie. De même, un forward peut être ajusté pour répondre à une date de livraison spécifique ou à des quantités exactes de produits, et une option peut être conçue avec des conditions particulières qui répondent aux stratégies de couverture ou de spéculation spécifiques d’un investisseur.

Types de produits dérivés OTC

  • Swaps : Contrats dans lesquels deux parties échangent des flux de trésorerie futurs selon des conditions préétablies. Par exemple, un swap de taux d’intérêt peut impliquer l’échange de paiements à taux fixe contre des paiements à taux variable.
  • Forwards : Contrats où deux parties s’engagent à acheter ou vendre un actif à une date future à un prix fixé aujourd’hui. Ces contrats sont souvent utilisés pour couvrir le risque de prix des matières premières.
  • Options : Contrats donnant le droit, mais non l’obligation, d’acheter ou de vendre un actif à un prix fixé à l’avance, à ou avant une date spécifiée. Les options OTC sont souvent personnalisées pour répondre aux besoins spécifiques des contreparties.

Processus de négociation des dérivés OTC

  1. Négociation des termes : Les termes des dérivés OTC sont négociés directement entre les parties, incluant le type de dérivé, la durée du contrat, et les conditions spécifiques.
  2. Évaluation et gestion des risques : Les deux parties doivent évaluer les risques associés au contrat et mettre en place des mesures pour les gérer, telles que la fourniture de garanties.
  3. Suivi et gestion des contrats : Une fois le contrat en place, les parties doivent suivre et gérer activement le contrat pour s’assurer qu’il reste conforme aux termes négociés et aux conditions du marché.

Avantages et risques des produits dérivés OTC

Avantages

  • Flexibilité : Les dérivés OTC peuvent être personnalisés pour répondre aux besoins spécifiques des parties impliquées.
  • Gestion des risques : Les dérivés OTC permettent aux entreprises de couvrir divers types de risques, tels que les risques de taux d’intérêt, de change et de prix des matières premières.
  • Optimisation des portefeuilles : Les dérivés OTC peuvent être utilisés pour améliorer l’efficacité des portefeuilles d’investissement en permettant une gestion plus fine des expositions aux risques.

Inconvénients

  • Risque de contrepartie : Le risque que l’une des parties fasse défaut sur ses obligations contractuelles. Pour minimiser ce risque, les institutions financières mettent en place des accords de garanties.
  • Complexité : La complexité des dérivés OTC peut rendre leur gestion difficile, nécessitant des compétences spécialisées et une surveillance continue.
  • Transparence : Les marchés OTC sont moins transparents que les marchés régulés, ce qui peut rendre l’évaluation des risques plus difficile.

Réglementation et compliance

Les produits dérivés OTC sont soumis à des réglementations strictes pour garantir la transparence et la sécurité des transactions. Par exemple, la réglementation EMIR (European Market Infrastructure Regulation) en Europe impose des exigences de reporting et de compensation pour les dérivés OTC. Durant mon stage chez Oddo BHF, nous devions nous assurer que toutes les transactions étaient conformes à ces régulations, souvent en collaboration avec le département de compliance.

Impact sur les marchés financiers

Les produits dérivés OTC jouent un rôle crucial dans les marchés financiers en offrant des outils pour la gestion des risques et l’optimisation des portefeuilles. Cependant, ils peuvent également contribuer à la volatilité et à l’instabilité des marchés en période de crise financière. Un exemple notable est la crise financière de 2008, où l’utilisation excessive des dérivés OTC a amplifié les risques systémiques.

Cas pratiques et exemples

Lors de mon stage chez Oddo BHF, j’ai été directement impliqué dans la gestion des dérivés OTC. Par exemple, nous avons travaillé sur des swaps de taux d’intérêt pour couvrir les risques de fluctuations des taux pour une entreprise multinationale. Cette entreprise souhaitait échanger ses paiements d’intérêts à taux variable contre des paiements à taux fixe pour stabiliser ses coûts de financement. Nous avons négocié les termes du swap en tenant compte des conditions spécifiques de l’entreprise et des prévisions de marché, ce qui a permis à l’entreprise de réduire son exposition aux risques de taux d’intérêt. Par ailleurs, selon la Banque des Règlements Internationaux (BRI), le volume total des transactions de produits dérivés OTC s’élevait à plus de 640 000 milliards de dollars au second semestre 2023, reflétant l’importance croissante de ces instruments dans les marchés financiers. De plus, les swaps de taux d’intérêt représentaient environ 75% de ce volume, soulignant leur prédominance. Les forwards et les options ont également connu une activité significative, avec des volumes atteignant respectivement 90 000 milliards et 65 000 milliards de dollars.

Comparaison avec d’autres instruments financiers

Dérivés OTC vs dérivés échangés en bourse

Les dérivés OTC offrent une plus grande flexibilité et personnalisation par rapport aux dérivés échangés en bourse, mais ils comportent également des risques accrus en termes de contrepartie et de transparence. Les dérivés échangés en bourse sont standardisés et compensés par une chambre de compensation, réduisant ainsi le risque de contrepartie.

Dérivés OTC vs autres produits financiers

Les dérivés OTC peuvent être utilisés en complément d’autres produits financiers tels que les obligations, les actions et les options échangées en bourse. Ils offrent des moyens supplémentaires pour la gestion des risques et l’optimisation des portefeuilles, mais nécessitent une expertise spécifique pour être gérés efficacement.

Conclusion

Les produits dérivés de gré à gré (OTC Derivatives) sont des outils puissants pour la gestion des risques et l’optimisation des portefeuilles en finance de marché. Ils offrent une flexibilité et une personnalisation accrues par rapport aux dérivés échangés en bourse, mais comportent également des risques importants qui doivent être gérés avec soin. Pour les étudiants et les futurs professionnels de la finance, comprendre les mécanismes et les enjeux des dérivés OTC est crucial pour naviguer efficacement dans ce domaine complexe.

Ressources utiles

Regulation on Over-the-Counter Derivatives and Market infrastructures – Frequently Asked Questions

À propos de l’auteur

Cet article a été écrit en juillet 2024 par Esten CHAUVIN, étudiant en Master de Management à l’ESSEC Business School, ancien stagiaire OTC Derivatives, Stock Loans, Repos chez Oddo BHF.

Guide de survie d’un stagiaire en finance de marché : Faut-il croire ChatGPT ?

Guide de survie d’un stagiaire en finance de marché : Faut-il croire ChatGPT ?

Esten CHAUVIN

Dans cet article, Esten CHAUVIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2023-2026) partage son expérience et ses conseils pour survivre et réussir en tant que stagiaire en finance de marché. Cet article est destiné aux étudiants qui s’apprêtent à commencer leur premier stage dans ce domaine exigeant mais passionnant.

Introduction

Un stage en finance de marché peut être intimidant, mais avec les bons outils et les bonnes astuces, vous pouvez non seulement survivre mais aussi prospérer. Voici un guide pratique pour vous aider à naviguer dans cet environnement dynamique et souvent stressant, en comparant les conseils généraux avec mon expérience réelle chez Oddo BHF.

1. Soyez ponctuel et organisé

Conseil général : La ponctualité est essentielle en finance de marché. Arrivez tôt, préparez votre journée et soyez prêt avant l’ouverture des marchés. Utilisez des outils comme des listes de tâches et des agendas pour rester organisé et gérer efficacement votre temps.

Mon expérience : Ce conseil est crucial. Arriver entre 7h30 et 8h me permettait de bien préparer ma journée avant l’ouverture des marchés à 9h. Utiliser des listes de tâches et des agendas électroniques m’a aidé à suivre les nombreuses responsabilités et à respecter les délais serrés. Mais attention, une liste de tâches interminable ne doit pas vous transformer en robot de la finance. Prenez le temps de respirer, un café à la main, tout en admirant la vue matinale sur l’A86 qui bouchonne sous la pluie.

Conseils supplémentaires :

  • Utilisez un carnet ou une application pour noter vos tâches quotidiennes.
  • Prévoyez un temps chaque matin pour organiser votre journée.
  • Anticipez les délais et planifiez à l’avance pour éviter les surprises de dernière minute.

2. Posez des questions et soyez curieux

Conseil général : Ne vous inquiétez pas si vous ne comprenez pas tout au début. La finance de marché est complexe et il est normal d’avoir des questions. Montrez votre intérêt et votre volonté d’apprendre en posant des questions pertinentes.

Mon expérience : Poser des questions est indispensable, mais il faut le faire de manière stratégique. J’ai appris à poser des questions après avoir fait mes propres recherches, ce qui montrait que j’étais proactif et désireux de comprendre en profondeur. Une recherche Google de 15 secondes peut souvent résoudre plus de problèmes qu’on ne le pense.

Conseils supplémentaires :

  • N’ayez pas peur de demander des clarifications à vos collègues ou supérieurs.
  • Faites des recherches supplémentaires pour approfondir votre compréhension.
  • Participez activement aux réunions et discussions.

3. Soyez proactif et prenez des initiatives

Conseil général : Ne vous contentez pas d’attendre que l’on vous donne des tâches. Proposez votre aide et cherchez des moyens d’apporter de la valeur à votre équipe. Votre initiative sera remarquée et appréciée.

Mon expérience : Être proactif est effectivement très apprécié. Proposer d’aider sur des projets ou d’améliorer certains processus m’a permis de me démarquer et de gagner la confiance de mon équipe. Attention cependant à ne pas vouloir tout révolutionner dès la première semaine. Commencez par de petites améliorations et gagnez petit à petit la confiance de vos collègues. Souvenez-vous, Rome ne s’est pas faite en un jour, et votre crédibilité non plus.

Conseils supplémentaires :

  • Identifiez les domaines où vous pouvez contribuer et proposez des solutions.
  • Saisissez les opportunités d’assumer de nouvelles responsabilités.
  • Montrez que vous êtes un membre actif et engagé de l’équipe.

4. Développez vos compétences techniques

Conseil général : En finance de marché, des compétences techniques solides sont indispensables. Familiarisez-vous avec les outils et logiciels utilisés dans votre entreprise et cherchez à améliorer continuellement vos compétences.

Mon expérience : Ce conseil est essentiel. Maîtriser Excel et d’autres outils analytiques m’a permis de gérer efficacement les tâches complexes. J’ai également appris à utiliser des plateformes de trading et des systèmes de gestion des risques spécifiques à mon entreprise. Maîtriser Excel en profondeur permet vraiment de gagner un temps fou et réussir à utiliser Excel sans toucher à votre souris vous permettra de gagner à coup sûr le respect de tous l’open space.

Conseils supplémentaires :

  • Maîtrisez Excel et d’autres outils analytiques couramment utilisés.
  • Apprenez à utiliser les plateformes de trading et les systèmes de gestion des risques.
  • Participez à des formations ou des webinaires pour rester à jour.

5. Soyez flexible et adaptable

Conseil général : Les marchés financiers sont imprévisibles et les priorités peuvent changer rapidement. Soyez prêt à vous adapter et à changer de cap lorsque nécessaire.

Mon expérience : La flexibilité est cruciale en finance de marché. Les situations peuvent évoluer rapidement, et il est important de rester calme et adaptable. Par exemple, lors de l’annonce de nouvelles économiques importantes, nous devions réagir rapidement pour ajuster nos stratégies. Rappelez-vous que l’imprévu fait partie du jeu et que chaque crise est aussi une opportunité de montrer votre capacité à gérer le stress avec grâce… ou du moins sans paniquer ouvertement.

Conseils supplémentaires :

  • Restez calme et professionnel, même en période de stress.
  • Adaptez-vous aux nouvelles situations et soyez prêt à apprendre de nouvelles compétences.
  • Maintenez une attitude positive et proactive.

6. Prenez soin de vous

Conseil général : Il est facile de se laisser submerger par le travail, mais il est important de prendre soin de votre santé physique et mentale. Faites des pauses régulières, mangez équilibré et assurez-vous de bien dormir.

Mon expérience : Ce conseil ne peut pas être sous-estimé. Travailler de longues heures peut être épuisant. J’ai trouvé qu’il était essentiel de prendre des pauses, de faire de l’exercice régulièrement et de maintenir une alimentation saine pour rester performant et éviter le burn-out. N’oubliez pas que le café et les 3 cigarettes du matin ne remplacent pas un bon petit déjeuner, et qu’une bonne nuit de sommeil vaut mieux que tous les compléments et produits énergisants possibles et imaginables.

Conseils supplémentaires :

  • Faites de l’exercice régulièrement pour réduire le stress.
  • Adoptez une alimentation saine et équilibrée.
  • Assurez-vous de dormir suffisamment chaque nuit.

Conclusion

Un stage en finance de marché est une expérience exigeante mais extrêmement enrichissante. En suivant ces conseils et en adoptant une attitude proactive et positive, vous maximiserez vos chances de succès et tirerez le meilleur parti de cette opportunité. Les conseils généraux peuvent vous donner une bonne base, mais adapter ces conseils à votre propre expérience et contexte est crucial pour réussir. Bonne chance !

Ressources utiles

How to Get an Internship in Finance par Handshake (2023)

HBR Guide to Finance Basics for Managers par Harvard Business Review (2012)

À propos de l’auteur

Cet article a été écrit en juillet 2024 par Esten Chauvin, étudiant en Master de Management à l’ESSEC Business School, ancien stagiaire OTC Derivatives, Stock Loans, Repo Loans chez Oddo BHF.

Compliance et régulation dans le secteur financier : focus sur les prêts de titres et les dérivés OTC

Compliance et régulation dans le secteur financier : focus sur les prêts de titres et les dérivés OTC

Esten CHAUVIN

Dans cet article, Esten CHAUVIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2023-2026) partage son expérience et ses connaissances sur la compliance et la régulation dans le secteur financier, avec un focus particulier sur les prêts de titres et les dérivés OTC.

Introduction

La compliance et la régulation jouent un rôle fondamental dans le secteur financier, garantissant la transparence et la sécurité des transactions. Cet article vise à expliquer les principaux aspects de la régulation en finance, en se concentrant sur les prêts de titres et les dérivés de gré à gré (OTC).

Importance de la compliance et de la régulation

Les régulations financières sont mises en place pour protéger les investisseurs, maintenir la stabilité des marchés et prévenir les pratiques frauduleuses. La compliance, quant à elle, assure que les institutions financières respectent ces régulations. Ensemble, elles forment le socle de la confiance dans le système financier.

Différence entre régulation et réglementation

La réglementation se réfère aux textes de lois, directives et règlements émis par les autorités compétentes pour encadrer les activités financières. Elle définit les règles et les normes que les institutions financières doivent suivre. La régulation financière, en revanche, est le processus par lequel ces règles sont mises en œuvre et appliquées. Elle inclut les activités de surveillance et de contrôle menées par les régulateurs pour s’assurer que les institutions se conforment aux réglementations en vigueur.

Origine et importance du reporting

Le reporting financier est né de la nécessité de fournir des informations transparentes et fiables aux régulateurs, investisseurs et autres parties prenantes. Il permet de suivre et d’évaluer les risques systémiques, de détecter les irrégularités et de garantir la stabilité du système financier. Par exemple, le reporting des transactions de prêt de titres et de dérivés OTC aide les régulateurs à surveiller les expositions et à prévenir les crises financières.

Principales régulations

  • Réglementation SFTR : La Securities Financing Transactions Regulation (SFTR) en Europe impose des exigences de reporting détaillées pour toutes les transactions de financement de titres. Cette régulation vise à augmenter la transparence et à réduire les risques systémiques.
  • Réglementation EMIR : L’European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR) impose des obligations de compensation et de reporting pour les dérivés OTC. Elle a été mise en place pour améliorer la transparence et réduire le risque de contrepartie.
  • Dodd-Frank Act : Aux États-Unis, cette loi impose des réglementations strictes sur les dérivés OTC, visant à prévenir une autre crise financière.

Compliance dans les prêts de titres

Les prêts de titres, ou stock loans, sont soumis à une surveillance réglementaire stricte. Les institutions doivent s’assurer que les transactions sont correctement déclarées et que les garanties sont adéquates.

Exigences de reporting

Les transactions de prêt de titres doivent être déclarées aux régulateurs dans un délai spécifique. Cela inclut des informations détaillées sur les parties impliquées, les titres prêtés et les garanties fournies.

Gestion des garanties

Les garanties doivent être évaluées régulièrement pour s’assurer qu’elles couvrent adéquatement le risque de contrepartie. Par exemple, si la valeur des titres prêtés augmente ou diminue significativement, des ajustements des garanties peuvent être nécessaires.

Exemple pratique

Pendant mon stage chez Oddo BHF, j’ai travaillé sur des transactions de prêt de titres où nous devions ajuster les garanties en fonction des fluctuations du marché. Nous collaborions étroitement avec le département de compliance pour nous assurer que toutes les transactions étaient conformes aux régulations en vigueur.

Compliance dans les dérivés OTC

Les dérivés OTC sont également fortement régulés pour garantir la transparence et la sécurité des marchés financiers.

Compensation et clearing

L’European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR) impose que certaines transactions de dérivés OTC soient compensées par des chambres de compensation centrales pour réduire le risque de contrepartie. Cela signifie que les parties impliquées dans une transaction doivent passer par une entité tierce qui garantit la transaction.

Exigences de reporting

Toutes les transactions de dérivés OTC doivent être déclarées aux régulateurs, incluant des détails sur les termes du contrat, les parties impliquées et les expositions au risque. Ces informations permettent aux régulateurs de surveiller les risques systémiques.

Exemple pratique

Durant mon stage, j’ai aidé à préparer des rapports de conformité pour les transactions de dérivés OTC. Cela impliquait de s’assurer que toutes les transactions étaient correctement enregistrées et que les expositions étaient gérées conformément aux régulations. Par exemple, une transaction de swap de taux d’intérêt nécessitait une déclaration précise et la mise en place de garanties adéquates.

Impact des régulations sur les opérations quotidiennes

Les régulations influencent fortement les opérations quotidiennes des institutions financières. Elles nécessitent des systèmes robustes pour le reporting et la gestion des risques, ainsi qu’une collaboration étroite entre différents départements.

Systèmes et technologies

Les institutions doivent investir dans des systèmes informatiques avancés pour gérer les exigences de reporting et de compliance. Cela inclut des logiciels de gestion des risques, des plateformes de reporting et des systèmes de suivi des garanties.

Formation et sensibilisation

Il est essentiel que tous les employés soient formés aux régulations et aux politiques de compliance. Cela inclut des sessions de formation régulières et des mises à jour sur les nouvelles réglementations.

Conclusion

La compliance et la régulation sont essentielles pour maintenir la confiance et la stabilité dans le secteur financier. Pour les étudiants et futurs professionnels de la finance, comprendre ces régulations est crucial. Les prêts de titres et les dérivés OTC sont deux domaines où la régulation joue un rôle particulièrement important, nécessitant une attention constante et une gestion rigoureuse.

Ressources utiles

ESMA – SFTR

ESMA – EMIR

À propos de l’auteur

Cet article a été écrit en juillet 2024 par Esten CHAUVIN étudiant en Master de Management à l’ESSEC Business School, ancien stagiaire OTC Derivatives, Stock Loans, Repo Loans chez Oddo BHF.

Le marché des Repos : Principe et stratégie

Le marché des Repos : Principe et stratégie

Esten CHAUVIN

Dans cet article, Esten CHAUVIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2023-2026) partage son expérience et ses connaissances sur le marché des Repos, leur principe et les stratégies associées en finance de marché.

Introduction

Les Repos, ou “repurchase agreements”, sont des instruments financiers couramment utilisés pour gérer la liquidité des institutions financières et financer leurs positions. Cet article vise à clarifier le principe des Repos et à expliquer les stratégies couramment utilisées.

Principe des Repos

Les Repos, ou accords de pension, sont des contrats financiers dans lesquels une partie (le vendeur) vend des titres à une autre partie (l’acheteur) avec l’engagement de les racheter à une date ultérieure à un prix convenu, généralement légèrement supérieur. Ce mécanisme permet au vendeur d’obtenir des liquidités à court terme tout en utilisant les titres comme garantie, tandis que l’acheteur bénéficie d’un placement sécurisé pour ses fonds excédentaires. En d’autres termes, le repo est une opération de financement à court terme qui offre une solution flexible pour la gestion de la trésorerie.

Parties prenantes

Les principaux acteurs dans un accord de repo sont le vendeur (souvent une institution financière cherchant à lever des liquidités) et l’acheteur (souvent une autre institution financière ou un investisseur institutionnel cherchant à investir des liquidités à court terme). Lors de mon stage chez Oddo BHF, j’ai pu observer ces interactions de première main. Nous collaborions fréquemment avec des contreparties telles que BNP Paribas, Société Générale, ainsi que des investisseurs institutionnels internationaux.

Processus des Repos

  1. Négociation des termes : Les termes de l’accord de repo sont négociés par les front offices des deux contreparties, incluant le type de titres, la durée de l’accord et le taux de repo. Le taux de repo représente les intérêts que le vendeur doit payer pour emprunter des liquidités à court terme en utilisant ses titres comme garantie et est généralement exprimé en pourcentage annuel.
  2. Transfert des titres : Une fois les termes acceptés, les titres sont transférés de manière sécurisée à l’acheteur.
  3. Fourniture des fonds : L’acheteur fournit les fonds au vendeur en échange des titres.
  4. Rachat des titres : À la fin de la période de repo, le vendeur rachète les titres au prix convenu et récupère ses titres. Les intérêts dus sur la période de l’accord sont calculés et payés au moment du rachat des titres. Par exemple, pour un accord de repo de 1 million d’euros avec un taux de 2% sur une période de trois mois, les intérêts seraient de 5 000 euros (1 000 000 € x 0,02 x 0,25), payés lors du rachat.

Types de garanties

Les garanties dans un accord de repo peuvent être des obligations d’État, des titres de créance d’entreprise ou d’autres titres financiers. Pour minimiser les risques de volatilité, nous travaillions principalement avec des obligations d’État, considérées comme des actifs à faible risque.

Calcul des taux de repo

Les taux de repo sont déterminés en fonction de plusieurs facteurs, dont le niveau de liquidité sur le marché, la durée du prêt et la qualité des titres utilisés comme garantie. Ces taux représentent les intérêts que le vendeur doit payer pour emprunter des liquidités à court terme en utilisant ses titres comme garantie. Durant mon stage, j’ai appris à négocier et à calculer ces taux en tenant compte des conditions du marché. Par exemple, les repos à court terme sur des obligations d’État françaises pouvaient avoir des taux plus bas en raison de la stabilité et de la liquidité de ces titres.

Stratégies des Repos

Stratégies pour les vendeurs

  • Gestion de la liquidité : Les vendeurs utilisent les repos pour lever des liquidités à court terme sans avoir à vendre définitivement leurs actifs. Par exemple, une banque peut utiliser un repo pour financer ses besoins de trésorerie quotidiens.
  • Optimisation du portefeuille : Les repos permettent aux institutions financières de gérer efficacement leurs portefeuilles en utilisant les actifs détenus comme garantie pour obtenir des fonds à court terme.

Stratégies pour les acheteurs

  • Placement sécurisé : Les acheteurs utilisent les repos pour placer des liquidités à court terme de manière sécurisée, en obtenant des titres en garantie.
  • Génération de revenus : En prêtant des fonds à des taux de repo compétitifs, les acheteurs peuvent générer des revenus supplémentaires sur leurs excédents de liquidité.

Enjeux des Repos

Avantages pour les parties prenantes

  • Pour le vendeur : Accès rapide à des liquidités, maintien de la propriété des titres, optimisation de la gestion de trésorerie.
  • Pour l’acheteur : Placement sécurisé des liquidités, génération de revenus à court terme, obtention de titres en garantie.

Risques associés

  • Pour le vendeur : Risque de défaut de l’acheteur, fluctuations de la valeur des titres en garantie.
  • Pour l’acheteur : Risque de ne pas récupérer les fonds prêtés si le vendeur fait défaut, volatilité des titres en garantie. Pour minimiser ces risques, nous ajustions régulièrement les garanties et surveillions les positions des contreparties. Par exemple, si nous utilisons des obligations d’État italiennes en garantie et que leur valeur chute soudainement, nous devons être prêts à demander une garantie supplémentaire pour couvrir le risque accru.

Réglementation et compliance

Les Repos sont soumis à une réglementation stricte pour garantir la transparence et la sécurité des transactions. Par exemple, en Europe, la régulation SFTR (Securities Financing Transactions Regulation) impose des exigences de reporting détaillées pour toutes les transactions de financement de titres. Durant mon stage de juillet à décembre 2023, nous devions nous assurer que toutes les transactions étaient conformes à ces régulations, souvent en collaborant étroitement avec le département de compliance.

Impact sur les marchés financiers

Les Repos contribuent à la liquidité des marchés en permettant une plus grande fluidité des titres et des fonds. Cependant, ils peuvent aussi influencer la volatilité et la stabilité des marchés, notamment en période de stress financier. Un exemple notable est l’impact des repos pendant la crise financière de 2008, où ces instruments ont joué un rôle crucial dans la gestion de la liquidité des institutions financières.

Cas pratiques et exemples

Pendant mon stage chez Oddo BHF, j’ai été directement impliqué dans la gestion de repos lors d’une période de tension sur les marchés financiers. Un exemple concret est survenu lors de l’annonce surprise de la Réserve fédérale américaine (Fed) en septembre 2023, lorsqu’ils ont décidé de maintenir les taux d’intérêt plus élevés que prévu. Cette annonce a entraîné une volatilité accrue sur les marchés des obligations d’État. Nous avions plusieurs accords de repo en cours avec des obligations françaises et italiennes. Avec la volatilité soudaine, nous avons dû ajuster rapidement les garanties et communiquer avec les contreparties pour s’assurer que les positions étaient couvertes. Cela a impliqué des négociations rapides et une coordination étroite avec les équipes de gestion des risques et de compliance pour s’assurer que toutes les transactions restaient conformes aux régulations en vigueur.

Comparaison avec d’autres mécanismes financiers

Repos vs prêts de titres

Les repos et les prêts de titres partagent des similitudes, comme l’utilisation de garanties. Cependant, les repos impliquent la vente temporaire d’un actif avec un accord de rachat , tandis que les prêts de titres concernent uniquement le prêt temporaire des titres sans vente.

Repos vs options et futures

Les repos et les dérivés financiers comme les options et futures sont utilisés pour la gestion des risques et la couverture. Cependant, les dérivés offrent des options de trading plus flexibles et des stratégies de gestion de portefeuille plus complexes par rapport aux repos.

Conclusion

Les Repos sont une pratique essentielle dans les marchés financiers, offrant des avantages significatifs aux vendeurs et aux acheteurs tout en présentant des risques qu’il convient de gérer avec soin. Pour les étudiants et les futurs professionnels de la finance, comprendre les mécanismes et les enjeux des Repos est crucial.

Autres articles sur le blog SimTrade

   ▶ Esten CHAUVIN Mon expérience chez OTC Securities Lending & Derivatives – Repo Loan

Ressources utiles

Pour approfondir vos connaissances sur les prêts de titres, voici quelques ressources recommandées :

SFTR (Securities Financing Transactions Regulation)

À propos de l’auteur

Cet article a été écrit en juillet 2024 par Esten CHAUVIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2023-2026) et ancien stagiaire OTC Derivatives, Stock Loans, Repo Loans chez Oddo BHF.

Les prêts de titres (stock loans) : fonctionnement et enjeux

Les prêts de titres (stock loans) : fonctionnement et enjeux

Esten CHAUVIN

Dans cet article, Esten CHAUVIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2023-2026) partage son expérience et ses connaissances sur les prêts de titres, leur fonctionnement et leurs enjeux en finance de marché.

Introduction

Les prêts de titres, aussi connus sous le terme “stock loans”, sont une pratique courante dans le monde financier. Ils permettent aux investisseurs d’optimiser l’utilisation de leurs titres tout en générant des revenus supplémentaires. Cet article a pour objectif de clarifier le fonctionnement des prêts de titres et d’expliquer les enjeux associés à cette pratique.

Fonctionnement des prêts de titres

Les prêts de titres sont un mécanisme où un propriétaire de titres prête ses titres à un emprunteur en échange d’une garantie et d’intérêts. Cela permet au prêteur de générer des revenus supplémentaires sans vendre ses actifs, optimisant ainsi l’utilisation de son portefeuille. Pour l’emprunteur, cette pratique offre la possibilité d’accéder temporairement à des titres sans avoir à les acheter, ce qui peut être crucial pour des stratégies telles que la vente à découvert ou la couverture de positions existantes.

Parties prenantes

Les principaux acteurs dans un prêt de titres sont le prêteur (souvent un fonds de pension ou une institution financière), l’emprunteur (généralement un trader cherchant à vendre les titres à découvert) et les intermédiaires comme les courtiers et les agents de prêt. Lors de mon stage chez Oddo BHF, j’ai pu observer ces interactions de première main, en travaillant avec divers acteurs pour assurer la fluidité des transactions. Par exemple, nous collaborions fréquemment avec des contreparties aussi bien nationales telles que BNP Paribas et Société Générale, qu’internationales comme Barclay’s ou Goldman Sachs.

Processus de prêt de titres

  1. Négociation des termes : Les termes du prêt sont négociés par les front offices des deux contreparties, incluant le type de titres, la durée du prêt et les frais. Ces frais, ou intérêts, sont calculés en fonction de la durée du prêt et du type de titres impliqués. Les modalités de paiement des intérêts, telles que la fréquence (mensuelle, trimestrielle) et la date de paiement, sont également définies lors de cette phase.
  2. Transfert des titres : Une fois les termes acceptés, les titres sont transférés de manière sécurisée à l’emprunteur.
  3. Gestion de la garantie : L’emprunteur fournit une garantie sous forme d’espèces ou d’autres titres. Cette garantie est ajustée régulièrement pour refléter les fluctuations de la valeur des titres prêtés. Par exemple, supposons qu’un emprunteur prête des actions d’une valeur de 1 million d’euros et qu’il fournisse une garantie de 1,1 million d’euros. Si la valeur des actions prêtées augmente à 1,2 million d’euros, l’emprunteur devra ajouter 100 000 euros supplémentaires à la garantie pour maintenir un ratio de couverture adéquat. À l’inverse, si la valeur des actions baisse à 900 000 euros, l’emprunteur peut récupérer 100 000 euros de la garantie. Ces ajustements, appelés appels de marge, sont cruciaux pour gérer le risque de marché et s’assurer que les intérêts des deux parties sont protégés.
  4. Restitution des titres : À la fin de la période de prêt, les titres sont restitués au prêteur et la garantie est libérée. Les intérêts accumulés pendant la durée du prêt sont payés à des intervalles définis (par exemple, mensuellement ou trimestriellement) et un dernier paiement d’intérêts est effectué lors de la restitution des titres. Ces paiements sont essentiels pour compenser le prêteur pour l’utilisation de ses actifs.

Il est primordial d’utiliser des systèmes avancés afin de garantir la sécurité et l’efficacité des très nombreuses transactions quotidiennes. Ces systèmes incluent des logiciels de gestion de risques, des plateformes de trading automatisées, et des systèmes de suivi et de reporting en temps réel. Par exemple, le tout premier deal que j’ai eu à gérer en débutant mon stage fut un prêt d’actions de TotalEnergies à un hedge fund basé à Londres. Nous avons utilisé une plateforme de trading pour exécuter la transaction et un système de gestion des risques pour évaluer et ajuster la garantie, qui était composée d’obligations d’État françaises. Ce type de transaction demande une coordination minutieuse pour s’assurer que les valeurs des actifs prêtés et reçus restent équilibrées, et cela n’est possible qu’avec des outils technologiques sophistiqués qui permettent de suivre et de sécuriser chaque étape du processus.

Types de garanties

Les garanties peuvent être des espèces, des obligations ou d’autres titres. Le type de garantie accepté dépend des termes du prêt et des politiques internes de l’institution financière. Afin de minimiser les risques de volatilité, j’ai principalement travaillé avec des garanties sous forme d’espèces.

Calcul des frais de prêt

Les frais de prêt sont calculés en fonction de plusieurs facteurs, dont le taux d’intérêt, la durée du prêt et le type de titres. Ces frais représentent le coût pour l’emprunteur d’accéder aux titres prêtés. Durant mon stage, j’ai appris à calculer ces frais en tenant compte des conditions du marché et des politiques internes. Par exemple, en novembre 2023, le prêt d’actions de TotalEnergies avait un taux d’intérêt annuel de 1,5%. Pour un prêt de 1 million d’euros sur trois mois, les frais étaient de 3 750 euros (1 000 000 € x 0,015 x 0,25). En comparaison, les actions de Tesla avaient un taux de prêt de 3,2%, ce qui entraînait des frais de 8 000 euros pour la même période (1 000 000 € x 0,032 x 0,25) en raison de leur forte demande.

Pair Off

Les “pair off” sont une technique couramment utilisée dans la gestion des prêts de titres. Il s’agit de l’annulation simultanée de deux transactions opposées, ce qui permet de réduire le volume des transactions en cours et de minimiser les risques associés. Par exemple, si une institution financière a prêté des titres à deux contreparties différentes qui souhaitent ensuite restituer les titres à la même période, les transactions peuvent être “pair off” pour simplifier le processus de restitution.

Enjeux des prêts de titres

Avantages pour les parties prenantes

  • Pour le prêteur : Génération de revenus supplémentaires à partir des titres détenus, optimisation de l’utilisation des actifs. Par exemple, un fonds de pension peut prêter des titres pour augmenter ses rendements.
  • Pour l’emprunteur : Accès temporaire à des titres sans achat direct, possibilité de couvrir des positions courtes. Un trader peut aussi emprunter des titres pour vendre à découvert.

Risques associés

  • Pour le prêteur : Risque de défaut de l’emprunteur, volatilité des garanties pouvant affecter leur valeur.
  • Pour l’emprunteur : Coût du prêt, risque de rappel des titres prêtés avant la fin prévue du prêt. Pour minimiser ces risques, nous ajustions régulièrement les garanties et surveillions les positions des emprunteurs. Par exemple, si nous prêtons des actions Apple à un hedge fund et que ces actions chutent soudainement, nous devions être prêts à appeler une garantie supplémentaire pour couvrir le risque accru.

Réglementation et compliance

Les prêts de titres sont soumis à une réglementation stricte pour garantir la transparence et la sécurité des transactions. Par exemple, en Europe, la régulation SFTR (Securities Financing Transactions Regulation) impose des exigences de reporting détaillées pour toutes les transactions de financement de titres. Durant mon stage, nous devions nous assurer que toutes les transactions étaient conformes à ces régulations, souvent en collaborant étroitement avec le département de compliance.

Impact sur les marchés financiers

Les prêts de titres contribuent à la liquidité des marchés en permettant une plus grande fluidité des titres. Cependant, ils peuvent aussi influencer la volatilité et la stabilité des marchés, notamment lorsqu’ils sont utilisés pour des ventes à découvert massives. Un exemple notable est l’impact des ventes à découvert pendant la crise financière de 2008, où les prêts de titres ont joué un rôle crucial dans la dynamique des marchés.

Cas pratiques et exemples

Pendant mon stage chez Oddo BHF, j’ai été directement impliqué dans la gestion de prêts de titres lors d’une période de forte volatilité du marché. Un exemple concret est survenu lors de la publication des résultats du Q3 d’un géant américain de la tech. Ces résultats étaient significativement en dessous des attentes, ce qui a entraîné une chute rapide du cours de l’action. Nous avions prêté des actions de cette entreprise à plusieurs hedge funds, et avec la baisse soudaine, la valeur de la garantie (collatéral) que nous avions reçue devait être ajustée rapidement pour couvrir le risque accru.

Dans cette situation, nous avons immédiatement contacté les contreparties pour augmenter la garantie en espèces afin de compenser la chute de la valeur des actions. Cela a impliqué des négociations rapides et une coordination étroite avec les équipes de gestion des risques et de compliance pour s’assurer que toutes les transactions étaient conformes aux régulations en vigueur.

Comparaison avec d’autres mécanismes financiers

Repos vs prêts de titres

Les repos (repurchase agreements) et les prêts de titres partagent des similitudes, comme l’utilisation de garanties. Cependant, les repos impliquent la vente temporaire d’un actif avec un accord de rachat, tandis que les prêts de titres concernent uniquement le prêt temporaire des titres sans vente.

Prêts de titres vs options et futures

Les prêts de titres et les dérivés financiers comme les options et futures sont utilisés pour la gestion des risques et la couverture. Cependant, les dérivés offrent des options de trading plus flexibles et des stratégies de gestion de portefeuille plus complexes par rapport aux prêts de titres.

Conclusion

Les prêts de titres sont une pratique essentielle dans les marchés financiers, offrant des avantages significatifs aux prêteurs et aux emprunteurs tout en présentant des risques qu’il convient de gérer avec soin. Pour les étudiants et les futurs professionnels de la finance, comprendre les mécanismes et les enjeux des prêts de titres est crucial.

Avec l’évolution des technologies et des régulations, les pratiques de prêt de titres continuent de se transformer. Les professionnels de la finance doivent rester informés et adaptables pour naviguer efficacement dans ce paysage en mutation.

Autres articles sur le blog SimTrade

   ▶ Esten CHAUVIN Mon expérience chez OTC Securities Lending & Derivatives – Repo Loan

Ressources utiles

Pour approfondir vos connaissances sur les prêts de titres, voici quelques ressources recommandées :

How stock loans financing works

À propos de l’auteur

Cet article a été écrit en juillet 2024 par Esten CHAUVIN (ESSEC Business School, Grande Ecole – Master in Management, 2023-2026) et ancien stagiaire OTC Derivatives, Stock Loans, Repo Loans chez Oddo BHF.