My experience as a sell-side equity research analyst

April 15, 2021 by Tanmay DAGA

My experience as a sell-side equity research analyst

In this article, Tanmay DAGA (ESSEC Business School, Global Bachelor of Business Administration, 2017-2021) introduces equity research, shares his internship experience at a top sell-side equity research company named Kotak Securities and gives his opinions on what the future holds for the industry.

About Kotak Securities

Kotak Securities was founded in 1994 as a subsidiary of Kotak Mahindra Bank and is headquartered in Mumbai, India. It is headed by Mr. Jaideep Hansraj who is a leading figure and has over 20 years of experience in the equity research industry. The company has over 1.7 million customer accounts and handles over 800,000 trades every single day making it one of the biggest brokerage houses in the country. The company handles operations in over 394 cities in India and is well poised for further expansion helping it expand its customer base. Kotak Securities offers stock broker services, portfolio management services, depository services, research expertise, dynamic market data and international reach for clients looking for investment opportunities overseas.

What is equity research?

It is a mainstream finance position which entails fundamental analysis and subsequent recommendation of public securities. Fundamental analysis is a method of evaluating the intrinsic value of an asset (future cash flows discounted to the present) and analyzing the factors that could influence its price in the future. Hence, equity research is an investigation based upon the core business drivers of a particular business which are reflected in its financial statements. Hence, equity researchers use financial statements combined with other industry and macroeconomic reports to form their opinion about a certain company or a universe of companies (also called coverage list). Investors such as money/managers use this information to better investigate their potential or existing investment decisions. To conclude, the main purpose of equity research is to provide investors with detailed financial analysis and recommendations on whether to buy, hold, or sell a particular stock. The professionals working in brokerage firms which sell analysis reports to investors are called sell-side analysts. Professionals working for mutual funds or hedge funds and who make direct investment decisions are called buy-side analysts.

Read an interesting interview with an industry expert who shares his experience of working in the industry.

Me and Finance

I had gotten enrolled in ESSEC’s GBBA in 2017 owing to my curiosity in finance and the university’s premier status, especially in finance. At the end of the first year, I had the opportunity to apply my mind and practically learn a few things along with it. It had always been my mission to work in finance, particularly in valuation. My fascination with valuation is simple – you are allowed to deem the situation as you see fit provided you have a logical reasoning behind it. Nothing can narrow the scope of your thoughts as long as they are realistic and reasonable. It is a great way for individuals to look at things from a broader perspective and develop an analytical mindset to help comprehend several moving parts simultaneously. It does take time getting used to the idea of having to dig into minute details but it’s worth it! Valuation is not purely science per se. It is a blend between sound analytical reasoning that helps you come up with a story (forecast as experts call it) and simple objective mathematics to help validate your story’s credibility. The fact that valuation today in investment banking and other fields looks so complicated is partly to mask the simplicity involved in the process so big banks can continue to charge hefty fees for what they do. Moreover, it is not a skill that will ever go in vain. The mindset a sound valuer develops helps him/her analyze the pros and cons any situation better than a counterpart. It is a skill that I recommend everyone to acquire.

My internship in Kotak Securities

In 2018, at the end of my first year of my GBBA at ESSEC Business School, I did an internship at Kotak Securities equity research division in Mumbai, India. I was 18 years old and comparatively new to equity research. Resulting, I witnessed a steep learning curve requiring me to learn and apply several concepts in a short span of time. My main responsibility was to help the fundamental research team carry out due diligence (financial analysis to analyse the true or intrinsic value of an asset and all other factors affecting this value) for the companies under our coverage universe. This was done by performing rigorous research for the company’s business, its supply chain, its value drivers and all other factors that affect its value and ultimately its stock price. The conclusions were to be presented to the senior management and the sales team along with a thorough explanation behind the rationale of selecting a particular stock for client recommendation. Based on the findings, recommendations were to be published in a bi-monthly analysis report which also included other important topics like the economic analysis of the current situation and trends in the currencies traded in foreign exchange (FX) market. As the organization was agile and flexible with what responsibilities members could take, I had the opportunity of working with several other departments aside from fundamental research. Some of the other projects I worked on were developing a proprietary algorithm based on analysis of trading patterns for index companies alongside the technical analysis team (which is the motivation for me in selecting the SimTrade course) and a model project on sentiment analysis – how news and company perception (especially on Twitter) affect the stock price in the short run. I learnt several hard skills such as modelling in Excel, literacy in reading company’s financial statements and intermediate level of coding in Python. Overall, it was a great work experience for me.

Key takeaways from my internship

During my time at Kotak, I have come across some important financial concepts that I believe every individual, irrespective of their affiliation with the finance industry, must truly understand. They will help you better understand financial issues and make sound investment decisions.

Inflation

Inflation refers to the sustained increase in the price of goods and services in an economy. This increase in price is hard to pinpoint at any one factor but more often than not, it is a combination of various factors. This could range from increase in labor prices to jump in raw material costs. As prices rise due to inflation, you’ll be able to afford less and less over a given period of time. That’s why it is imperative to understand that long-term savings must be invested in a manner by which the returns surpass the inflation rate. That’s the only way one can continue to afford to buy more in a definite time period in the future. In many countries, the only reliable way to beat inflation is investing in stocks/equities. As Bonds or Bank savings do not offer any positive real interest realization.

Diversification

Diversification is a risk management strategy that mixes a wide variety of investments within a portfolio. A diversified portfolio contains a mix of distinct asset types and investment vehicles in an attempt at limiting exposure to any single asset or risk. The rationale behind this technique is that a portfolio constructed of different kinds of assets will, on average, yield higher long-term returns and lower the risk of any individual holding or security. This is a widely approved method for protecting capital against unexpected events in the global markets. By using the primary study of correlation, investors can diversify certain risk away. However, data on correlation is historical and thus, backwards looking, and might not always hold true in the future. For instance, during the shutdown of the global economy in March 2020, multiple assets like stocks, commodities and bitcoin (which have not been positively correlated in the past) collapsed together. All have had a positive recovery together since (again implying positive correlation as opposed to results from previous studies).

Time Value of Money

The time value of money (TVM) is the concept that money you have now is worth more than the identical sum in the future due to its potential earning capacity. This core principle of finance holds that provided money can earn interest, any amount of money is worth more the sooner it is received. For instance, assume a sum of $10,000 is invested for one year at 10% interest. The future value (FV) of that money is: FV = $10,000 x (1 + 10%) = $11,000. The formula can also be rearranged (reversed) to find the value of the future sum in present day dollars. For example, the present value (PV) of $5,000 one year from today, compounded at 7% interest, is: PV = $5,000 / (1 + 7% ) = $4,673.

TVM is also sometimes referred to as present discounted value. This is a fundamental pillar on which company valuation is based. The true value of a company is the future free cash flows the company generates, discounted to the present time using an appropriate discount factor.

Future of equity research: my personal view

Equity research is an important role that has come into prominence since the bull market in the 1950s. Thousands of fund managers handling trillions of dollars in assets under management often use sell-side research to get an outsider’s opinion before making investment decisions. Certainly, the size of the industry has shrunk significantly since buy-side and IB analysts are being better compensated, causing a shift in the workforce. However, things are not bad. Companies are now letting analysts focus more on analysis than on sales. This is certainly going to attract new talents who want to focus purely on analysis.

Read this interesting counter-view on the future of the industry.

Relevance to SimTrade

This course helps in understanding the other side of the same coin – technical analysis (using price movements and other factors to predict the future of a security). Participants of this course can expect to gain practical knowledge about stock trading by using a real-world like simulator where multiple strategies can be applied and tested. Other benefits include gaining a broad understanding of the financial markets and concepts.

Useful resources

Kotak Securities

Corporate Finance Institute Example of equity research report

About the author

The article was written by Tanmay DAGA (ESSEC Business School, Global Bachelor of Business Administration, 2017-2021).

My experience as a portfolio manager in a central bank

November 29, 2020 by Youssef LOURAOUI

My experience as a portfolio manager in a central bank

During my studies at ESSEC Business School, I had the chance to attend the SimTrade course. This course helped me to secure an internship as a risk manager at Bank Al-Maghrib (the central bank of Morocco) as I was asked during my interviews technical questions about financial markets that were covered during the course.

In this article, Youssef LOURAOUI (ESSEC Business School, Global Bachelor of Business Administration, 2020) shares his experience as an intern in the risk management department (middle office) at the Central Bank of Morocco (Bank Al-Maghrib) in 2020.

Bank Al-Maghrib

The central bank of Morocco was founded in 1959 after Morocco proclaimed its independence. It is a 100% state-owned bank that regulates the markets and the economy by implementing monetary and economic policies to ensure the welfare in terms of the parity of prices and the control of inflation. Inflation is a major economic indicator that possesses strategic importance and is part of the major focus for the central bank.

Bank Al-Maghrib

I describe below my experience at Bank Al-Maghrib.

My internship at Bank Al-Maghrib

I was affected at the middle office department, which is in charge of measuring risk exposures and profits and losses on the positions taken by the bank on an investment portfolio of 27,4 billion euros of foreign reserve. One of the key risk exposure metrics is volatility measured by the standard deviation statistically defined as the dispersion of a random variable (asset prices or returns in my case) from its expected value. The standard deviation indicates how much the current return is deviating from its expected historical returns. It is one of the most widely used metrics for investors when analyzing the risk of an investment. Among other key exposures metric, there is what it is called the VaR (Value at Risk) at 99% and a 95% confidence level for 1-day and 30-day positions. In other words, the VaR is a metric used to compute how much loss can the portfolio incur at a % degree of confidence for a given time horizon.

Every day, the Head of the Middle Office organizes a general meeting where he talks about global debriefing of the main financial news that happened overnight and debriefing the middle office desk for the “watch out” assets that could have a potential investment opportunity. Accordingly, the team has also the task of staying in line with the investment decision that characterizes the organization, as it does not operate as an investment banking corporation nor a hedge fund in the risk and leverage used. As the central bank has the special task of keeping safe the national reserve and searching for a good mix to invest in a low risk asset (AAA bonds from European countries coupled with American treasury bonds).

My task aimed to get a hand on the investment mechanism in the middle office of the bank. The investment mechanism consists of the division of the overall portfolio into three main tranches where each one has its characteristics. The first tranche (called also the security tranche) is calculated by analyzing the national need for a currency that needs to be kept safe to establish welfare on the exchange market (based mainly on short term position in low-risk profile asset (Liquid and high rated bonds). The second tranche is based on buy and hold and a market strategy. The first one consists of taking a long position on more risky assets than the first tranche till maturity, there is no selling during the lifetime of the asset (riskier bonds and gold). The second strategy is based on buying and selling liquid assets for an expectation of yielding higher returns.

During my time at the middle office desk, I’ve managed to develop a tool to represent the investment mechanism used for asset allocation. The tool, developed in an Excel spreadsheet, is an intuitive and simplified model that enables the understanding of the investment mechanism. Indeed, it is capable of continuously refreshing the data by importing the most recent quotations (from data providers like Bloomberg or Reuters as the two main financial data providers) to allow for an update of the different exposures and thus allow to respect the proportions of portfolio allocations. It has also a dynamic risk management tool to effectively compute draw-downs (a peak-to-trough decline during a specific period for an investment) and stressed conditions, as I experienced how the markets reacted to the novel Covid-19 pandemic with one of the most historic market movements in a long time.

Some of the key learning outcomes:

The introduction to data analysis by manipulating large datasets

Portfolio optimization based on the Markowitz efficient frontier

Dynamic portfolio allocation based on the fundamentals of the modern portfolio theory

The theory of efficient markets to understand how the markets evolve and move in a different direction as a reaction to events.

Front office, middle office and back office

My internship was also a good opportunity to discover the different departments of the bank: the front office, the middle office, and the back office:

The front office directly deals with the individual or corporate clients of the bank. Salespeople propose adequate products and solutions to the clients (they are in front of them!). Traders intervene in the financial markets on behalf of the clients or for the bank itself (proprietary trading). To answer the demand of clients, financial engineers and quants also develop new products and the associated mathematical models to price them. One of the main trends that are emerging in the front office is the automatization with the help of AI and algorithmic trading that is taken some room in the trading desks. At this time the bank didn’t implement any technology based on high-frequency trading, but it is taking the financial industry by surprise and it goes a long way back, nearly decades ago since the first usage of algorithmic trading.

The middle office situated between the front office and the back office (somewhere in the middle!) deals with the risk management of the bank. Risk managers control the traders’ positions (respect of constraints such as value-at-risk limits and stress tests) and compute the profits and losses (P&L) on traders’ positions daily.

The back-office deals with the conformity and the security check of every trade to ensure a proper settlement.

Note that the frontiers between the front, middle, and back-office may change from one bank to another. And last but not the least, the IT people are also supporting all three departments to make the whole system work. In other words, they are in charge of the maintenance of the technical infrastructure that the bank uses daily to operate fluently, as all the departments are dependent on internal software to intermediate and operate in the market or to communicate between each department of the bank or with another organization. The IT desk has great importance in offering a flawless experience for the employees when using the internal electronic infrastructure. There is the backbone of the bank skeleton.

All in all, the SimTrade module served me well as I managed to gain quickly the necessary knowledge and bridge the gap that I had to be in the best position to achieve the missions I’ve been affected. I especially used the content of Period 2 of the SimTrade certificate, which deals with market information. The concepts of trading and investing were also obviously useful for the development of my portfolio management tools.

Useful resources

Bank of Morocco

About the author

The article was written in November 2020 by Youssef LOURAOUI (ESSEC Business School, Global Bachelor of Business Administration, 2020).