Analysis of the Movie Fair Play (2023): Gender and Power in High Finance

William LONGIN

In this article, William LONGIN (MSc Financial Mathematics at Queen Mary University of London, 2026-2027) analyzes the Fair Play movie (2023) through the lens of gender and power in high finance.

Set in a Manhattan hedge fund, Fair Play (2023) explores the fragile balance between ambition, intimacy, and gender dynamics in high finance. At the center of the story are Emily and Luke, a young couple with contrasting archetypes: the ambitious woman whose competence is constantly scrutinized and the seemingly supportive man whose sense of identity remains tied to traditional expectations of success. A pivotal promotion transforms what should be a professional achievement into a struggle over status, recognition, and power. In an industry that claims to reward performance above all else, Fair Play raises a fundamental question: whether meritocracy can truly exist when perceptions of competence remain shaped by gender.

Poster of the Fair Play movie (2023)
Fair Play movie (2023)
Source: Netflix.

Film summary

Written and directed by Chloe Domont, Fair Play (2023) follows Emily (Phoebe Dynevor) and Luke (Alden Ehrenreich), two analysts at a Manhattan hedge fund who keep their engagement secret at work. Luke expects to be promoted, but Emily gets the job and becomes his boss. His initial support gives way to resentment as he begins to question how she got ahead.

The firm’s treatment of Luke and Emily after the fund’s $25 million trading loss illustrates how gender may shape who is held accountable for investment failures. As tensions mount, Luke reveals their relationship during an investor presentation, putting Emily’s credibility at risk and bringing their professional rivalry into the open.

What Fair Play reveals about high finance

Why Wall Street was historically dominated by men

For much of Wall Street’s history, getting into investment banking or brokerage depended on who would recommend you. Firms recruited through educational, family, and professional networks that were already dominated by men. Muriel Siebert, an established securities analyst, struggled to find sponsors before becoming the first woman to hold a seat on the New York Stock Exchange in 1967. The way financial careers were organized also mattered. Research by Marianne Bertrand, Claudia Goldin and Lawrence Katz found that differences in working hours and career interruptions helped explain why men and women with similar earnings after business school earned increasingly different amounts over time. For women in the study, those differences in hours and interruptions were largely associated with motherhood.

Whose success needs explaining?

When Campbell promotes Emily, he points to the investment calls she made the previous quarter. Some of her colleagues speculate that she got the job by sleeping with him. Later, Campbell tells Emily that he hired Luke as a favor to a friend. Luke still believes he is waiting for a fair chance to prove himself. At a firm that prides itself on rewarding performance, the personal connection that secured Luke’s job goes unremarked, while Emily’s promotion invites suspicion despite her track record.

Why Luke is not considered for promotion

At a hedge fund, a portfolio manager has to keep a clear head when a trade goes wrong or a colleague challenges an idea. Luke struggles with both. He presses Emily to approve a trade before finishing the analysis she asked for. When it costs the fund $25 million, his first response is to point out that other firms made the same bet. Eager to recover the loss, he proposes shorting a company using material non-public information. Trading on such information may constitute illegal insider trading under U.S. securities laws, raising serious legal and ethical concerns.

Luke also takes professional setbacks personally. When he gets a minute to pitch in front of Campbell, he spends it talking about how much he admires him and wants to follow in his footsteps. However, his speech says little about how well he would manage a portfolio. His lack of emotional self-control becomes particularly evident when he interrupts an investor presentation to air his grievances, putting Emily in the position of having to manage the fallout in front of clients. The outburst reveals his inability to separate personal grievances from professional responsibilities. Luke wants the authority of a portfolio manager, yet he struggles to stay composed when his judgment is questioned or a decision goes against him.

Power and organizational culture: the price of belonging

Beyond formal promotions and investment decisions, the Fair Play movie examines how power operates through the unwritten social conventions of a male-dominated financial institution. At One Crest Capital, professional influence is not exercised exclusively through organizational hierarchies. It also emerges through informal relationships, social rituals, and access to spaces in which professional alliances are reinforced such as high-end restaurants. Success therefore depends not only on analytical competence but also on an individual’s ability to navigate the firm’s culture.

This dynamic becomes particularly visible following Emily’s successful trading decision, when she accompanies her male colleagues to a strip club. The scene functions as more than a celebration of financial performance. It illustrates the informal social environment through which employees demonstrate loyalty, reinforce relationships, and establish their place within the group. For Emily, participation represents an attempt to consolidate her professional legitimacy by engaging in the same activities as her male counterparts. Yet the apparent inclusiveness of the occasion conceals an underlying double standard: behavior considered acceptable for male colleagues becomes a source of criticism when performed by a woman.

Luke’s subsequent reaction exposes this contradiction. Rather than interpreting Emily’s participation as part of her professional integration, he presents it as evidence that she has compromised her identity and values. The scene highlights the conflicting expectations placed on women in traditionally masculine workplaces. Emily is expected to demonstrate the assertiveness, competitiveness, and social adaptability associated with leadership, while simultaneously remaining within conventional boundaries of femininity. Fair Play thus portrays workplace inclusion as a conditional process in which women may gain access to positions of authority without necessarily escaping the gender norms that shape perceptions of their behavior.

From professional rivalry to personal domination: when power crosses boundaries

Emily’s promotion reverses the traditional hierarchy that Luke implicitly expects, revealing how closely his sense of self-worth is connected to professional status. His growing resentment reflects a broader tension between changing gender roles and persistent assumptions about masculinity, achievement, and control.

The aftermath also exposes the limitations of institutional responses to workplace misconduct. Campbell’s preference for transferring the matter to human resources and restoring business as usual suggests an organizational priority placed on operational continuity rather than a deeper examination of the underlying workplace culture. Meanwhile, Luke’s plans to pursue a new venture through family connections reinforce the film’s earlier critique of privilege and informal networks. Even after his professional and personal collapse, he continues to envisage opportunities supported by relationships outside the formal meritocratic system.

Campbell promotes Emily on merit. He points to her investment calls when he gives her the job and rewards her with a substantial bonus after her successful recovery trade. Luke initially congratulates her, then starts questioning whether she earned the promotion once he has to answer to her. Campbell is comfortable giving Emily more authority while she still reports to him. The film leaves open whether he would be equally comfortable if their positions were reversed. It is one thing to recognize a colleague’s talent when you have the final say. Would Campbell still trust Emily’s judgment if the final say were hers?

Finance and management concepts related to the movie

Hedge fund

A hedge fund is a pooled investment vehicle that typically employs relatively flexible investment strategies. A fund can buy shares it expects to rise or take a short position to profit if a share price falls. At One Crest Capital, analysts such as Luke research investment opportunities and recommend trades. Portfolio managers such as Emily evaluate these recommendations, make investment decisions, and manage the portfolio’s exposure to risk. The $25 million trading loss illustrates the importance of investment decision-making and risk management, as well as the distinction between recommending and approving a trade.

Double standard

A double standard arises when people in comparable situations are judged by different criteria. In Fair Play, Luke initially takes the prospect of his own promotion as recognition of his ability. When Emily gets the job, he questions whether her investment record was enough to earn it. Campbell’s decision gives the scene its force. He promotes Emily because of the calls she made for the fund. The double standard is in Luke’s response. He readily credits his own ability when he expects to advance, then looks for another explanation when Emily advances and becomes his boss.

Why should I be interested in this post?

Through the professional and personal rivalry between Emily and Luke, this article puts into words a question explored by the film’s writer and director, Chloe Domont: How readily do we accept someone’s authority when their success changes our own position? Emily earns her promotion on merit, and Luke’s response shows how quickly admiration can give way to resentment when he has to answer to her. If the film’s message was less apparent on a first viewing, this article can make it clearer.

Related posts on the SimTrade blog

Movies about finance

   ▶ All posts about Movies and Documentaries

   ▶ William LONGIN Netflix ‘Billions’ Analysis of characters through CFA Code and Standards

   ▶ Akshit GUPTA Film analysis: Margin Call (2011)

Financial techniques

   ▶ Akshit GUPTA Insider trading

Useful resources

About the movie

Fair Play Netflix Media Center.

Chloe Domont discusses the ending Netflix Tudum.

Chloe Domont breaks down the trading-loss scene Entertainment Weekly.

Academic resources about gender and finance

Bertrand, M., Goldin, C., & Katz, L. F. (2010). Dynamics of the Gender Gap for Young Professionals in the Financial and Corporate Sectors. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 2(3), 228–255.

Egan, M. L., Matvos, G., & Seru, A. (2022). “When Harry Fired Sally: The Double Standard in Punishing Misconduct.” Journal of Political Economy, 130(5), 1184–1248.

Roth, L. M. (2006). Selling Women Short: Gender and Money on Wall Street. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

About the author

The article was written in November 2026 by William LONGIN (MSc Financial Mathematics at Queen Mary University of London, 2026-2027).

   ▶ Discover all posts by William LONGIN.