Lilian BALLOIS

M&A Strategies: Benefits and Challenges

by

M&A Strategies: Benefits and Challenges

Lilian BALLOIS

In this article, Lilian BALLOIS (ESSEC Business School, Bachelor in Business Administration (BBA), 2019-2023) explains about the M&A Strategies.

Reminder: What are Mergers & Acquisitions?

M&A (short for Mergers and Acquisitions) refers to the processes of combining two or more companies into a single entity or the purchase of one company by another. These activities are typically undertaken to achieve specific objectives such as expanding market share, gaining competitive advantages, increasing efficiency, or accessing new technologies.

In a merger, two companies come together to create a new entity, while in an acquisition, one company acquires another, which may result in the acquired company becoming part of the acquiring company or continuing to operate as a subsidiary.

What are the five main M&A strategies?

M&A activities can take various forms and involve different strategies, such as vertical mergers, horizontal mergers, conglomerate mergers, market extension and product extension. Each approach comes with its own set of benefits and challenges.

Vertical strategy

Vertical strategy.
Vertical strategy
Source: The author

A vertical strategy involves the consolidation of two or more businesses operating at different stages of the supply chain to create an integrated product or service. A notable example of a vertical merger is the merger between Walt Disney and Pixar Animation Studios in 2006 for $7.4 billion. The merger drove growth between the businesses. The benefits of a vertical strategy include increased operational efficiency, lower operating costs, higher profits, and improved quality control. On the other hand, challenges may arise from opposing company cultures, potential loss of key team members due to role combinations, and increased bureaucratic costs.

Horizontal strategy

Horizontal Merger.
Horizontal Merger
Source: The author

A horizontal strategy involves two businesses within the same industry merging to eliminate competition. A good example of a horizontal merger is the merger between Exxon and Mobile in 1998 for $75.3 billion. This strategy offers benefits such as increased revenue, diversification of products and services, a larger market reach, and reduced competition. Nonetheless, it comes with challenges, including heightened regulatory scrutiny, decreased business mobility, less control over decision-making, and the risk of providing less value to customers compared to pre-merger offerings.

Conglomerate strategy

Conglomerate Merger.
Conglomerate Merger
Source: The author

A conglomerate strategy involves merging two companies with distinct business activities, either through pure mergers, where each company continues operating independently in their respective markets, or mixed mergers, involving product and market extensions. In 2017, Amazon acquired Whole Foods Market for $13.7 billion. The merger enabled Amazon to step foot in the grocery sphere and Whole Foods accessed Amazon’s vast customer base to boost its sales. The benefits of a conglomerate merger include a larger market share, business diversification, and increased revenue through cross-selling. However, challenges may arise, including reduced efficiency, conflicts in workplace cultures, and a shift in core business values that could lead to friction with customers and stakeholders.

Market extension strategy

Market extension strategy.
Market extension strategy
Source: The author

The acquisition of LinkedIn (valued at $26.2 billion) by Microsoft from 2016, illustrates a market extension strategy, uniting two entities that offered distinct services — Microsoft’s technology and productivity solutions with LinkedIn’s professional networking platform. While both companies operated in different spheres of the market, the merger aimed to create synergies by integrating their respective strengths. The benefits of this merger allowed Microsoft to broaden its reach and enhance services by tapping into LinkedIn’s extensive database of professional connections. For LinkedIn, the benefits were an expanding client base and market presence. However, challenges such as increased business responsibility, higher capital requirements, and the potential for accumulating debt were factors that need careful consideration in the post-merger landscape.

Product extension strategy

Product extension strategy.
Product extension strategy
Source: The author

An example of a product extension merger is when Pepsi Co acquired Pizza Hut in 1977. This merger involved two companies operating in the same market, offering complementary products designed for joint consumption. Pepsi Co’s acquisition of Pizza Hut aimed to diversify their offerings and tap into a broader customer base. By linking Pizza Hut exclusively to Pepsi beverages, Pepsi Co expanded sales and market reach. Within a year of the merger, Pizza Hut sales exceeded $436 million. Benefits of product extension mergers include an expanded customer base, shared resources, and reduced operational costs through collaboration. However, challenges such as potential market clutter and confusion, as well as decreased efficiency in production and marketing efforts, may arise. Despite these challenges, the primary advantage lies in creating a “mega product” that leverages a wider customer base, while the downside involves the risk of market saturation and reduced operational efficiency.

Ensuring fair competition

L’Autorité de la Concurrence

The French competition authority (Autorité de la Concurrence), uses several mechanisms to prevent mergers and acquisitions from resulting in anti-competitive practices:

  1. Merger Control Review: The Autorité de la Concurrence conducts a review of proposed mergers and acquisitions to assess their potential impact on competition. It evaluates factors such as market concentration, barriers to entry, and the likelihood of unilateral or coordinated effects that could harm competition.
  2. Market Analysis: The authority conducts market analyses to understand the dynamics of relevant markets affected by the merger or acquisition. This analysis helps to identify potential competition concerns and assess whether the transaction could lead to the creation or strengthening of a dominant market position.
  3. Assessment of Efficiencies: While examining mergers and acquisitions, the Autorité de la Concurrence also considers potential efficiencies that could benefit consumers, such as cost savings, improved product quality, or innovation. These efficiencies must outweigh any potential harm to competition.
  4. Imposition of Resorts: If the authority identifies competition concerns arising from a merger or acquisition, it may impose resorts to address them. Resorts can include divestitures of overlapping businesses or assets, licensing agreements, behavioral commitments, or other measures designed to preserve competition in affected markets.
  5. Legal Enforcement: If a merger or acquisition raises significant competition concerns and cannot be resolved through resorts, the Autorité de la Concurrence can prohibit the transaction outright. It can also impose fines or other sanctions for violations of competition law.

Securities and Exchange Commission

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) focuses on regulating securities markets and protecting investors, rather than directly overseeing antitrust aspects of mergers and acquisitions. Nevertheless, the SEC plays a crucial role in ensuring transparency and fairness in the disclosure of information related to M&A transactions, which indirectly contributes to preventing anti-competitive practices.

Here’s how the SEC helps ensure that M&A activities do not lead to anti-competitive practices:

  1. Disclosure Requirements: The SEC mandates that companies involved in M&A transactions disclose relevant information to shareholders and the public. This includes details about the terms of the merger or acquisition, potential risks, and the rationale behind the transaction. By providing comprehensive and accurate disclosures, the SEC helps investors make informed decisions and promotes transparency in M&A transactions.
  2. Enforcement of Securities Laws: While the SEC’s primary focus is on enforcing securities laws rather than antitrust laws, it may investigate M&A transactions if they involve violations of securities regulations. For example, the SEC may investigate cases of insider trading or fraudulent activities related to M&A deals.
  3. Proxy Statement Review: The SEC reviews proxy statements filed by companies involved in M&A transactions to ensure compliance with disclosure requirements. Proxy statements contain essential information about the proposed transaction, like details about the parties involved, the terms of the deal, and potential conflicts of interest. Through its review process, the SEC helps to ensure that shareholders receive accurate and complete information about M&A transactions.
  4. Regulation of Tender Offers: The SEC regulates tender offers to protect shareholders from coercive or fraudulent practices. Companies making tender offers must comply with SEC regulations regarding disclosure and fairness to shareholders. The SEC may intervene if it identifies any irregularities or violations of securities laws in tender offers.

While the SEC’s role in directly preventing anti-competitive practices in M&A transactions is limited, its oversight of disclosure requirements and enforcement of securities laws contribute to promoting transparency, fairness, and investor protection in the M&A process. Additionally, the SEC collaborates with other regulatory agencies, such as the Department of Justice (DOJ) and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), which have primary responsibility for enforcing antitrust laws related to mergers and acquisitions.

Why should I be interested in this post?

This post offers a comprehensive understanding of Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A) strategies, providing insights into the benefits and challenges associated with various approaches. Covering the five main M&A strategies – vertical, horizontal, conglomerate, market extension, and product extension – the post dives into real-world examples. Readers will gain a deeper understanding of how different M&A strategies are implemented, their advantages as well as the challenges they may encounter. Whether you’re a business professional looking to expand your knowledge of M&A or a student delving into strategic management, this post offers valuable insights into the complexities of M&A strategies in today’s corporate landscape.

Related posts on the SimTrade blog

   ▶ Louis DETALLE A quick presentation of the M&A field…

   ▶ Louis DETALLE How does a takeover bid work & how is it regulated?

   ▶ Raphaël ROERO DE CORTANZE In the shoes of a Corporate M&A Analyst

   ▶ Rick MARCHESE Difference between a merger and an acquisition

Useful resources

Academic References

Bernile, G., Lyandres, E. and Zhdanov, A. (2011) A theory of strategic mergers European Finance Review, 16(2) 517–575.

A practical guide to mergers, acquisitions, and divestitures Delta Publishing Company

Specialized References

McKinsey & Company

PwC (2020). Mergers & Acquisitions

Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)

Autorité de la Concurrence

Reuters Mergers and Acquisitions

Bloomberg

About the author

The article was written in February 2024 by Lilian BALLOIS (ESSEC Business School, Bachelor in Business Administration (BBA), 2019-2023).

Discovering Private Equity: Behind the Scenes of Fund Strategies

by

Discovering Private Equity: Behind the Scenes of Fund Strategies

Lilian BALLOIS

In this article, Lilian BALLOIS (ESSEC Business School, Bachelor in Business Administration (BBA), 2019-2023) explains about Private Equity fund strategies.

Reminder: What is Private Equity?

Private Equity entails investors directing capital into privately held enterprises that are not publicly traded on stock exchanges. Private Equity firms manage investors’ funds, which are utilized to secure ownership stakes in these companies, fostering their growth, innovation, or resolution of financial challenges. In exchange, investors anticipate yielding profits upon exiting the investment, typically within a span of 5 to 8 years.

Private equity thus offers a way for companies to receive strategic financing and for investors to earn returns on their investments, in an alternative way to traditional investments.

But how do you know which funds to invest in?

Decoding Success: How to choose the perfect Private Equity Investment Strategy

Aligning Investments with the Company Lifecycle

Private equity investments are aligned with various stages of a company’s lifecycle (Cf. chart below). In the early stages, venture capital provides funding for startups to assist in innovation and growth. As companies mature, growth equity offers expansion capital to fuel further development and market penetration. In the maturity stage, private equity often engages in leveraged buyouts (LBOs) to acquire established companies, implementing operational enhancements and strategic changes to boost efficiency and profitability. Finally, distressed capital may be deployed to support struggling businesses, offering resources and expertise to facilitate turnaround efforts.

Company life cycle.
Company Life Cycle
Source: The author

Venture Capital: at the Introduction Phase

Venture Capital is a private equity and financing approach focused on supporting early-stage startups and high-potential businesses. Investors, including affluent individuals, investment banks, and angel investors, contribute funds to fuel the growth of these companies. Apart from monetary contributions, investors may also offer technical or managerial expertise. An illustrative example of Venture Capital at work is Uber, which in 2010 received its initial major funding of $1.3 million led by First Round Capital. Shortly after, in early 2011, it raised $11 million in a Series A funding round led by Benchmark. With these funds, Uber expanded its operations to various cities in the United States and abroad, including Paris, where the concept originated. By December of 2011, Uber secured $37 million in Series B financing from Menlo Ventures, Jeff Bezos, and Goldman Sachs, further fuelling its global expansion and technological advancements.

Growth Equity: at the Growth Phase

Growth equity is a less speculative form of financing, aids companies in their expansion phase. Unlike venture capital, growth equity is directed at already profitable and mature businesses with minimal debt. This type of funding, commonly involving minority ownership through preferred shares, facilitates strategic business growth, such as entering new markets or acquiring other companies, with a balanced risk-return profile. Adyen, a prime example, initially self-funded, but experienced exponential growth after securing $250M in Series B funding led by General Atlantic in 2014. This injection of capital significantly accelerated Adyen’s trajectory, leading to its successful IPO on Euronext in June 2018, with a market capitalization of €7.1B. Adyen’s subsequent revenue surge to €721.7 million in 2022 further underscores the potency of growth equity in fuelling sustained business growth.

Leveraged Buyouts & Management Buyouts: during the Maturity Phase

Leveraged Buyouts

Leveraged Buyouts (LBOs) funds combine investment funds with borrowed capital to acquire companies, aiming to enhance profitability. By leveraging creditors’ and investors’ money, the fund manager has more capital to purchase larger companies, either outright or by securing a majority stake for strategic control. The term “leveraged buyout” reflects the use of borrowed funds to afford larger acquisitions, potentially resulting in substantial returns if the strategies pay off. An instance of an LBO is Elon Musk’s acquisition of Twitter, Inc. Despite initial resistance from Twitter’s board, who employed a “poison pill” strategy to deter hostile takeovers, Musk’s persistent pursuit led to the acceptance of his buyout offer of $44 billion on April 25.

Management Buyouts

Management Buyouts (MBOs) are transactions in which the existing management team of a company acquires a significant ownership stake or complete ownership of a business. In a MBO, the current managers collaborate with a private equity firm to purchase the business from its existing owners. This transaction is common when a company’s management team believes they can run the business more effectively or exploit growth opportunities better than the current ownership structure allows. The MBO of Dell Inc. in 2013 stands out as one of the largest and most significant in history. With a valuation reaching approximately $24.9 billion. The company’s founder, Michael Dell, partnered with Silver Lake Partners to reclaim control of the company he had founded. The move allowed Dell to implement long-term strategies and make pivotal decisions without the immediate pressures of quarterly earnings reports, facilitating a more nimble and adaptable approach to the rapidly evolving tech landscape.

Distressed Capital: at the Decline Phase

Distressed capital consists in lending to companies facing financial crises and to take control of businesses during bankruptcy or restructuring processes. The strategy involves purchasing distressed companies at a lower price, turn them around, and eventually sell them. Distressed capital carries inherent risk due to investing in financially challenged companies. For example, in May 2020, Hertz Global Holdings, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy due to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on its business, which saw a significant decline in travel demand. During its bankruptcy proceedings, Hertz secured funding from distressed debt investors to support their operations and restructuring efforts. This financing came from a consortium of lenders and institutional investors, providing Hertz with the liquidity needed to continue operations, pay essential expenses, and navigate the bankruptcy process.

Timeless Investing: Optimizing Portfolios through Vintage Year Diversity

What are “Vintage Years”?

“Vintage years” refer to specific time periods during which a fund was raised or initiated. Each vintage year represents a cohort of funds that were raised and deployed within a similar timeframe. These vintage years are often used by investors and analysts to track the performance of funds over time, as funds raised in the same vintage year may encounter similar market conditions and economic environments, which can affect their overall performance and returns.

Mitigating market cycles

Private equity has demonstrated superior performance compared to public equity throughout market cycles. However, returns are subject to fluctuations based on the phase of the business cycle. For instance, if a fund initiates investments during a downturn, it is likely to encounter a broader array of distressed and undervalued assets, with the potential for profitable exits when the market peaks. Conversely, a fund entering the market at its highpoint may face challenges as assets are likely to be expensive and may risk undervaluation upon entering public markets during the exit phase.

Given the unpredictability of market timing, diversification across vintages serves as a strategic approach to dampen this cyclical risk. This approach aims to create a more stable return profile that mirrors the overall characteristics of the asset class.

Establishing a self-sustaining portfolio

Company life cycle.
Self-funding Portfolio
Source: The author

As written above, funds can diversify through various vintages. This strategy allows to generate returns from an earlier vintage, which are reinvested as commitments for a subsequent vintage. In doing so, a self-funding portfolio is cultivated, steadily appreciating in value over time.

Exploring Sectors of Private Equity Investments

In 2023, technology continued to lead private equity investments, capturing a significant 31% share of total investments. Cloud-related ventures, especially enterprise Software as a Service (SaaS), remained appealing, fueled by expectations of sustained growth. Additionally, the rapid adoption of machine learning, driven by global enterprises integrating generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) into operations, signaled a broader trend towards innovation.

Consumer-focused investments, accounting for 14% of total investments, saw a focus on low-risk ventures in the food and agribusiness sector. Sustainable farming, combined agriculture, and timber ventures stood out, driven by increasing emphasis on environmental sustainability and responsible resource management.

In addition, financial services (11%) and health sectors (9%) saw significant private equity activity. In finance, investments spanned various subsectors, reflecting a pursuit of diverse opportunities. Meanwhile, health sector niches like enterprise imaging solutions and voice-based diagnostics attracted attention, driven by innovation in medical technology platforms, highlighting the sector’s transformative potential.

PE deals by sector.
Sectoral Share in Private Equity Deal Values
Source: Moonfare

The private equity landscape in 2023 featured a diverse range of investment opportunities, with technology dominating while consumer, financial services, and health sectors also drew significant interest, providing distinct pathways for growth and value generation.

Why should I be interested in this post?

This post offers a comprehensive overview of private equity investing. It defines private equity and explores various investment strategies such as venture capital, growth equity, leveraged buyouts, management buyouts, and distressed capital, providing practical insights into their roles at different stages of a company’s lifecycle. Additionally, the post discusses the concept of vintage years and their significance in tracking fund performance over time, highlighting the importance of portfolio diversification and risk management.

   ▶ Louis DETALLE A quick presentation of the Private Equity field…

   ▶ Louis DETALLE A quick review of the Growth Capital…

   ▶ Louis DETALLE A quick review of the Venture Capitalist’s job…

   ▶ Matisse FOY Key participants in the Private Equity ecosystem

   ▶ Marie POFF Film analysis: The Wolf of Wall Street

Useful resources

Academic References

Martin, J. and R. Manac (2022) Varieties of funds and performance: the case of private equity, The European Journal of Finance, 28(18) 1819–1866.

EVCA (2007) Guide on Private Equity and Venture Capital for Entrepreneurs

Caselli, S. and M. Zava (2022) Private Equity and Venture Capital Markets in Europe

Specialized Press

Investment Strategies in private equity

Barber F. and M. Goold (2023) The strategic secret of private equity Harvard Business Review

Private Equity Pulse: key takeaways from Q4 2023

Financial Times Private Equity

Wall Street Journal Private Equity

About the author

The article was written in February 2024 by Lilian BALLOIS (ESSEC Business School, Bachelor in Business Administration (BBA), 2019-2023).

My professional experience as a property manager assistant at Urban Premium

by

My professional experience as a property manager assistant at Urban Premium

Lilian BALLOIS

In this article, Lilian BALLOIS (ESSEC Business School, Bachelor in Business Administration Program, 2019-2023) shares his professional experience as a property manager assistant at Urban Premium.

About the company

Founded in 2010, Urban Premium specializes in the structuring and management of real estate investment trusts (REITs). The company specializes in the management of residential and commercial SCPIs (Société Civile de Placement Immobilier). A SCPI is a collective investment undertaking in the form of a company that is not listed on the stock exchange. SCPIs collect money from many investors with the sole aim of acquiring and managing a property portfolio for rental. Urban Premium specializes in inner-city real estate investment, incorporating attractive tax incentives like “Pinel/Denormandie”, “Malraux” and “Déficit Foncier”.

The Pinel and Denormandie instruments offer tax reductions for the construction or renovation of real estate in specific areas of France, based on the duration of the lease.

The Malraux Law promotes investment in high-quality real estate, often in city centres and protected areas, offering an income tax reduction.

The Déficit Foncier allows for reducing tax pressure by generating a deficit through investments in properties requiring renovations, deductible from rental income.

Logo of Urban Premium.
Logo of Urban Premium
Source: Urban Premium

As a property manager assistant, I was able to work alongside the front office managers. It was the central unit within the company, and it was responsible for implementing the investment strategy in line with tax incentives (Pinel/Denormandie, Malraux, and Déficit foncier). The front office was made up of one Managing Director, 5 managers and me.

In addition to these responsibilities, our department played a crucial role in managing funds and making strategic decisions. This involved overseeing the allocation of resources across various investment channels, ensuring optimal utilization of available funds while adhering to risk management protocols. Furthermore, our team engaged in market research and trend analysis to identify opportunities.

My internship

I had a 6-month internship at Urban Premium as an assistant property manager.

My missions

During my 6-month internship from September 2022 to February 2023, I engaged with multiple investment opportunities and projects. I took on the responsibility of analysing and crafting pitch-books for weekly meetings with managers when investment opportunity booklets were received. In addition to this, I had to monitor the accounting sheets of the real estate funds, analyzing, and providing insightful comments on their performance. While also overseeing fundraising to a lesser extent, my internship enabled me to understand the complexities of regulatory compliance concerning tax incentives for real estate finance and portfolio management within my company.

Required skills and knowledge

To be able to work in a real estate investment fund, it is necessary to have certain key skills:

  • Financial analysis to assess the profitability and viability of real estate investments.
  • A certain degree in accounting knowledge to understand and manage financial sheets. Particularly, you need a good knowledge of property valuation and lease accounting.
  • The ability to implement and analyse benchmarks to evaluate investment performance relative to the market.
  • Some background knowledge of the mechanisms of real estate markets and investment strategies.
  • Excellent communication skills to collaborate effectively with team members, partners, and investors.
  • Mastery of IT Tools, notably Excel.
  • Especially for the fund in which I was employed, knowing the principles of the different tax systems (Pinel, Malraux and Déficit Foncier).

What I learned

During my internship at Urban Premium, I learned new concepts and solidified the knowledge I already had. The hands-on experience provided through my internship gave me understanding of the management of real estate investment portfolios. Other important aspects of my internship were analyzing and contributing to the assessment of investment opportunities, navigating the complexities of project financing, and honing my skills in financial analysis.

Financial concepts related my internship

(Real estate) Financial analysis

Real estate financial analysis is the process of evaluating the financial aspects of property investments. It involves a comprehensive examination of various financial metrics and considerations to determine the profitability and feasibility of a real estate venture. This analysis encompasses factors such as property values, rental income, operating expenses, financing costs, and potential returns on investment.

Investment opportunity evaluation

Evaluation of an investment opportunity is the process of assessing the viability and potential returns of a specific investment. It involves an analysis of financial data, market trends, risks, and potential rewards. This evaluation aims to provide decision-makers with an understanding of the investment’s feasibility and align it with the overall goals and strategies of the investor or organization.

Portfolio Management

Portfolio management is the strategic and systematic process of overseeing and optimizing a collection of financial assets (real estate in this case), known as a portfolio, to achieve specific investment goals.

Why should I be interested in this post?

This post provides insights into the professional experience of working as a property manager assistant at a real estate investment trust (REITs) and managing residential and commercial SCPIs. It delves into real estate finance, including French tax incentives such as “Pinel/Denormandie”, “Malraux”, and “Déficit Foncier”. Additionally, the post outlines the responsibilities and skills required for working REITs, making it a must-read for anyone interested in pursuing a career in this field or seeking to enhance their knowledge.

Related posts on the SimTrade blog

   ▶ All posts about Professional experiences

   ▶ Arthur EVERARD My experience as a Real Estate Analyst at Eaglestone

   ▶ Clément KEFALAS My experience of Account Manager in the office real estate market in Paris

Useful resources

Urban Premium

About the author

The article was written in February 2024 by Lilian BALLOIS (ESSEC Business School, Bachelor in Business Administration Program, 2019-2023).